x

You have decided to merge your account with the GOG.com.

You can now start participating in the community discussions.

x

You chose to opt out from the merge process.
Please note that you will not be able to access your account until you opt in.

We strongly encourage you to merge your RED account with the GOG.com one.
If you want to do it later please try logging in again.

  • Register

Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

"The Stack" in Gwent [Timing of Multiple Effects]

Collapse
X
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • "The Stack" in Gwent [Timing of Multiple Effects]

    Is there anywhere that details the order of operations for the stack in Gwent?

    There seem to be many cards that have special priority. Coming from a Magic background, where the stack is "first on, last off" it's really frustrating in Gwent at times trying to figure out what triggers are going to happen first when a card is played.

    Also, some triggers just don't work at all like I would expect them to based on their description on the card.

    Thoughts, feelings?
    Last edited by Rawls; 18-11-16, 20:22. Reason: Invited insults (I understand it was a joke, but we're not going to go down the rabbit hole of trying to figure out what insults are jokes and which aren't).

  • #2
    I'm not quite sure what you mean but from my experience I've tailored my Northern Realms deck to counter all of the other decks. You just have to understand what all your opponents cards can do. When they pull out something new I remember it can anticipate it for future games against that faction. What do you mean by cards don't work as expected?

    Comment


    • #3
      I grew up with The Stack, and it's frustrating jumping into new games that don't have something as fundamentally solid. I truly love The Stack and miss it all the time. This isn't just Gwent that misses it, a lot of games for some reason leave many interactions up to individual cards and leaves lots of ambiguity on the table. Gwent seems to use a priority ladder (as we saw in the patch with savage bear) that, as long as the priorities are logical, everything is fine. but this seems like a roundabout and overly complicated way of going about it that will just require lots of meticulous planning and tweaking (again, as we saw in the patch with bear, as well as the skellige discard units).
      Last edited by Rawls; 18-11-16, 20:23. Reason: Insult (I understand it was a joke, but we're not going to go down the rabbit hole of trying to figure out what insults are jokes and which aren't).

      Comment


      • #4
        Originally posted by gamingdevil800 View Post
        I'm not quite sure what you mean but from my experience I've tailored my Northern Realms deck to counter all of the other decks. You just have to understand what all your opponents cards can do. When they pull out something new I remember it can anticipate it for future games against that faction. What do you mean by cards don't work as expected?

        OK, few examples. There is bear in play that damage each new unit and I play new unit into weather. Will first weather reduce power to 1 and unit die to bear or is it other way around so bear has practically no effect. In this case weather go last. Now I use Chani and return 8 power unit into weather, in this case weather first turn her to 1 power unit and after that Chani changes it gold. I play Priscila when there is that bear doing damage. In this case Priscila die first, so her ability does nothing. Same situation but I play Dandelion, in this case Dandelion ability happen first, then he dies to bear.

        And for god sake, don't ask me how that elf that get +3 each time special cards is played should work. What happen when somebody plays DBomd, did he gain bonus first and than bomb happens and reset the bonus or is it opposite. And what if I play that special that does 3 damage to row, will he survive on 2 or not? What if I play weather. No idea, man.

        Indeed some rules for this game will be nice, I really did not like losing because in many cases I have no idea in which order game resolves all the triggers. But yeah I used to be Magic pro player and judge, so maybe I'm asking to much and modern games does not work this way.
        Last edited by darklord23; 18-11-16, 20:30.

        Comment


        • #5
          Originally posted by darklord23 View Post


          OK, few examples. There is bear in play that damage each new unit and I play new unit into weather. Will first weather reduce power to 1 and unit die to bear or is it other way around so bear has practically no effect. In this case weather go last. Now I use Chani and return 8 power unit into weather, in this case weather first turn her to 1 power unit and after that Chani changes it gold. I play Priscila when there is that bear doing damage. In this case Priscila die first, so her ability does nothing. Same situation but I play Dandelion, in this case Dandelion ability happen first, then he dies to bear.

          Indeed some rules for this game will be nice, I really did not like losing because in many cases I have no idea in which order game resolves all the triggers.
          Originally posted by darklord23 View Post


          OK, few examples. There is bear in play that damage each new unit and I play new unit into weather. Will first weather reduce power to 1 and unit die to bear or is it other way around so bear has practically no effect. In this case weather go last. Now I use Chani and return 8 power unit into weather, in this case weather first turn her to 1 power unit and after that Chani changes it gold. I play Priscila when there is that bear doing damage. In this case Priscila die first, so her ability does nothing. Same situation but I play Dandelion, in this case Dandelion ability happen first, then he dies to bear.

          Indeed some rules for this game will be nice, I really did not like losing because in many cases I have no idea in which order game resolves all the triggers.
          This sounds like a bug to me I've been in situations against that bear card and have been able to play priscilla/use her ability before she dies.

          Comment


          • #6
            For those not familiar with"The Stack" in Magic, it is where all actions are placed before they are resolved. So if you play a card, it goes on the stack, any actions that are triggered because of that card being played then go on the stack. The actions are resolved from top to bottom. So the first thing to resolve is that last action that was put on the stack. the card that was played that triggered everything resolves last. Thus - First on, last off.

            It is an order of operations, just like in mathematics that can be easily predicted based on what happened first. its sort of hard to explain sorry.

            Gwent does not operate this way.

            Comment


            • #7
              They have actually changed the priorities of some cards lately. It would be nice to either have a more clear priority list though, as it does seem that some cards have a higher priority than others, even though we can't see it until after the fact. Maybe they should add a general rule. Played cards go before cards on the board, something like that.

              Comment


              • #8
                Originally posted by schidzo View Post
                They have actually changed the priorities of some cards lately. It would be nice to either have a more clear priority list though, as it does seem that some cards have a higher priority than others, even though we can't see it until after the fact. Maybe they should add a general rule. Played cards go before cards on the board, something like that.
                A broad rule like this might help a bit, but it wouldn't solve the issue with multiple in-play effects, such as bear+weather. what i can tell, most of the problems is interactions between Units and Specials, so maybe priority can go by Type => Special effects happen first, then Units (or vice versa).

                Comment


                • #9
                  Originally posted by gamingdevil800 View Post


                  This sounds like a bug to me I've been in situations against that bear card and have been able to play priscilla/use her ability before she dies.

                  Could somebody confirm this, I'm really interested. Because before patch, if there was damaging bear and I played Priscila or Hawker Healer (1 power that gives +3 to row), they died to bear before their effect happened for sure, I tried this couple of times. Did they really change this with patch? If so, I lost couple of games because I did not play Hawker Healer into bear thinking it would not have his effect and it is quiet huge deal when you have row with 8 units.

                  Edit: Thinking about this, they probably change it only for Priscilla, because she now work more like Dandelion, you play one or revealed cards instead of putting 2 card in play. So effects that let you play card happens before damage from bear, but effect that put cards into play / buff other units happens after. But I really would like know logic how this should work. Hard to report bug when we have no idea how are cards supposed to work.
                  Last edited by darklord23; 18-11-16, 20:59.

                  Comment


                  • #10
                    Originally posted by darklord23 View Post
                    Same situation but I play Dandelion, in this case Dandelion ability happen first, then he dies to bear.
                    Actually its the other way around now. They changed the bear priority, it triggers first than almost everything now, even priestess of freya. I already had games were i dropped dandelion and he died to bear effect before commanders horn. Other game my opponent dropped priestess and she died before resurrecting.

                    Other effect that has really high priority is roach coming from the deck. It is placed before any golden card effect can trigger.

                    Hawker support on the other hand now almost always act last as i could tell. If you lacerate it with 2 strength, he will die before he can buff.

                    Comment


                    • #11
                      Stack and Batch (for really Old MtG players) are/were nice conventions for organizing effects. One thing in Gwent that would prevent the same solution is that a unit dying before using it's ability doesn't get to use that ability (as opposed to MtG where the ability itself would be on the stack, and still resolve even if the creature died before it resolves).

                      I've been thinking about this a bunch over the last two weeks. I wonder if something as generic as this could help:

                      (Resolve from top down)
                      Enter the battlefield (ETB) effects resolve first
                      Weather (if any)
                      Self-buff effects
                      Board Buff Effects
                      Self Damage Effects
                      Board Damage Effects

                      With something like this, at least results could be mostly consistent and predicted. With any given order there will be cases that are worse than current, and cases that are improved; however, my informal notes say this seems the most likely to adversely effect the smallest number of cards.

                      Thoughts, ideas, BGCs?
                      V/R

                      Treamayne

                      Theme Decks - New Player Tips - Non-bug FAQ - PB Known Issues Thread - Bug/Feedback Submission Form

                      Comment


                      • #12
                        So far i assumed they have. Cards on the board befor played cards. Some cards are bugged too.

                        Comment


                        • #13
                          Originally posted by Treamayne View Post
                          I've been thinking about this a bunch over the last two weeks. I wonder if something as generic as this could help:

                          (Resolve from top down)
                          Enter the battlefield (ETB) effects resolve first
                          Weather (if any)
                          Self-buff effects
                          Board Buff Effects
                          Self Damage Effects
                          Board Damage Effects


                          Thoughts, ideas, BGCs?
                          Is this an example of how you think it should work or its actually how you think it works now?

                          Because definitely it isnt how it works now. Gwent has individual cards priorities, and not by effect types. For example the savage bear case that i highlighted on my last post here.

                          Comment


                          • #14
                            I play with savage bear/s a lot and last night I played against someone who used Priscilla, she died before using her ability. The opponent kept resurrecting her only for her to be shot down. At one point I had two bears and played a Priestess of Freya card and she also died before I could res with her.
                            Main faction: Skellige :P

                            Comment


                            • #15
                              Originally posted by Akiraana View Post
                              I play with savage bear/s a lot and last night I played against someone who used Priscilla, she died before using her ability. The opponent kept resurrecting her only for her to be shot down. At one point I had two bears and played a Priestess of Freya card and she also died before I could res with her.
                              That's logical IMO. First the unit needs to come into play, then it can use it's abilitiy. Same reason why redanian elites played into rain get debuffed and then promoted.

                              +1 for THE STACK. It is intuitive, easy to remember and easy to resolve. Latest triggered ability resolves first, then the next and so on.

                              Comment

                              Working...
                              X