You got confused, i never said Geralt keeps his feelings or emotions for Yen, especially his love, if that's what you mainly referred too, after the amnesia, I said he remains to be the changed person that he is after living such things. By how your comment reads, its as if Geralt with amnesia or without it would be exactly the same person to you except he remembers the past in the later, well, remembering the past changes a person and his feelings and emotions deeply in my opinion.
I also never assumed Geralt's relationship with Triss isnt currenty strong compared to that the one with Yen now, but I'll just take it as a generalization that you just used to give an example and hopefully didnt meant include me in it.
And about the books, well if you're tired of seeing games compared to the books, don't read the comments past the part where you see someone refers to the books in a thread related to the game, I on the other hand think you can compare pretty much anything with anything and get something valuable and insightful of it if you do it properly and organized, especially when its in a way that one doesnt use later to try to change everything to personally fit his own taste or opinion.
In my second paragraph, in case you also misunderstood me or assumed wrong things, i want to clarify that I meant that that's what i think CDPRED will do for TW3, not what I want, its speculation.
Regarding this "As a matter of fact the games are RPGs, and so each player's Geralt might be different from the next. And people would enjoy the games more if they just imagined they have lost their memories like Geralt, and would forget about the books. Let CDPR to reintroduce you to the books in the Witcher 3 and go with the flow. "
I agree with it mostly, but I think a lot of people love to get into the role of a pre-existing and defined character rather than also creating him/her besides role-playing, and im fine with that, I know we dont "create" Geralt but an amnesia Geralt is closer to a blank character more than just regular Geralt, and in fact, i've experienced the taste of this myself, not all the times in RPGs I like my char to be either a fully blank page, or a partially blank page, especially when we take into account that a TON of RPGs suffer from terrible writing, choice and consequences implementation, and social relationships portrayal, only because they must give you freedom, but thats another subject, perhaps for another thread.