That's black and white thinking tbh...you take extreme realism to defend extreme unrealism...
I said you should read my suggestions for a reason. Extreme realism to the point that you even have to go to the toilet was never demanded by anyone here.
There is no such thing as "extreme" realism; Realism is just that. What you are now talking about is a compromise toward realism for the sake of gameplay, which is exactly what we already have. "Extreme unrealism", as you call it, would be no inventory limits at all and you can carry a thousand swords... that is not what CDPR is doing.