Correct me if I'm wrong but I don't think the dialogue option after the meeting with Emhyr changes depending on what you did at the end of the last wish quest.
Regarding the Kaer Morhen lake incident.My problem wasn't the conversation before she teleported us into the lake, but the non-existent conversation after. We can't confront her about the teleport, but just have to accept it. As if Geralt deserved to be teleported into a lake, just because Yennefer was in a bad mood and Geralt provoked her a bit.
I agree with that but that's my problem. Games Geralt and books Geralt are not the same persons. . Geralt is our character to some extent, since CDp used the Amnesia to allow us that . And I think it worked pretty well, except for the interactions with Yen. He is 100% books Geralt in this moments and not my Geralt anymore. I would have liked to get the option to stay games Geralt during this moments. And Witcher 1, 2 or 3 Geralt is not submissive towards anybody. (well except Yen). We even get the possibility to contradict emhyr- the most powerful man in the witcher world.
Take the first meeting with Yen in Vizima. Geralt asks her a simple and legit question "what does the hunt want from Ciri" Yennefer responds annoyed with " I have no clue Geralt . Might've written them to ask, but I don't have their address". Geralt's response? Nothing, he looks like he wants to say something but just shuts up.
This is just an example but represents the many interactions between Geralt and Yen during the game.
So many times we can her something and she either straight tells us she doesn't need to answer that or does it in a sarcastic way and we just have to accept hat. Again, what happened to Geralt's famous sarcasm when he is with Yen?
Remember that dwarf in White orchard who was sarcastic after Geralt asked him what happened? We get the chance to respond to his sarcasm but are denied to do so whenever Yennefer says something.Sure, Yennefer is not some random Dwarf but especially after the last wish quest CDP should have given us the options to not do and accept everything Yennefer wants and says.
Back to the Vizima meeting. Then we can ask her why she didn't contact us earlier and she responds that she didn't want to "spoil our fun with Triss". She dismisses Geralt's explanation that he lost his memory and we just have to accept that. Why didn't we get the opportunity to ask her about Serrit? You know that guy she tried to seduce, while she lost her memory. But no, Geralt just stands there like an idiot and says nothing and basically accepts that he has done wrong, while Yen is right.
How many times in the game we actually get the chance to oppose her behavior? I think the conversation option after the meeting with Emhyr before Kaer Morhen is the only one and again Geralt behaves submissive.
Geralt: "Ah i see, So you show your claws to me because I'm a lowly Witcher, but.."
Yen interrupts.....; "Do you really to do this now, Geralt? We can fight another time, in another place . Where the walls have no ears."
That's it. Finally Geralt found his balls to ask Yen why she treats him that way and she just wipes off his question by saying that this is not the time and Geralt just accepts it. I don't need to say that that conversation never happens.
I made a thread awhile back about this specific issue, the title was "Geralt becoming a shadow of himself." It was closed due to the shitstorm that followed it. Granted I was only focusing on the negatives at this point and in hindsight I realize not everything is black. There are good moments and they are very nice too. Yet I did read it with a "calm" mind just now before I decided if I was going to link it or not and I realize it is still mostly valid. Feel free to make your own opinions on the subject, maybe you'll agree or maybe not. In any case, here it is:
http://forums.cdprojektred.com/thre...ss-and-how-Geralt-becomes-a-shadow-of-himself