2 things I wish were fixed - Dijkstra and Saskia (spoilers)
Disclaimer - I consider TW3 astonishing achievement and my favourite game of all time. It is in fact so good, that these imperfections stand out a bit more because of that.
1. Dijkstra - he is one of the best characters in the books AND in TW3. CDP writers absolutely nailed him in every way, as did the voice actor.
Which only makes his last 5 minutes on the scene even more heartbreaking - not because it is sad, but simply because it was completely out of character. Him going after Geralt was completely illogical and bizzare. I think everyone can agree on that.
Even still - if it would require too much work to rework that part of the game, I at least wish we could dispatch him without slaying him like a common bandit. For example if it was possible to Axii him and then knock him unconscious, I would be a lot happier with that. Although of course ideally his "last scene" would be rewritten to make more sense.
Is there any possibility to see this happen?
2. Saskia - I went with Iorveth in TW2 (to me that path is more fun, and makes more sense, since Geralt would go with his friend Zoltan IMO). Saskia is one of my favourite characters in TW2, so I decided to cure her. I was saddened when I found out she was not present in TW3 (4 years ago, I started a thread here asking "which characters do you want to see in TW3" and Saskia was the first I mentioned). Then I was glad, when in dialogue with Philippa, that I can at least ask about Saskia.
Imagine by disappointment when Geralt asks Philippa:
"Did she manage to get herself free of your spell?"
I mean, I freaking cured her. I imported the save. So perhaps Geralt should not be asking this
Philippa says that she lost control of Saskia when the war broke out and does not know where she is.
So at least she is alive.
Still, I would like to see that line ammended to reflect what was done in TW2 - it was really jarring like this.
Ideally of course I would love to see Saskia again, as well as Villentretenmerth, in a DLC/Expansion
Then there are few more things story related that could stand improvement (Wild Hunt/Eredin etc) but those have been elaborated a lot here.
Disclaimer - I consider TW3 astonishing achievement and my favourite game of all time. It is in fact so good, that these imperfections stand out a bit more because of that.
1. Dijkstra - he is one of the best characters in the books AND in TW3. CDP writers absolutely nailed him in every way, as did the voice actor.
Which only makes his last 5 minutes on the scene even more heartbreaking - not because it is sad, but simply because it was completely out of character. Him going after Geralt was completely illogical and bizzare. I think everyone can agree on that.
Even still - if it would require too much work to rework that part of the game, I at least wish we could dispatch him without slaying him like a common bandit. For example if it was possible to Axii him and then knock him unconscious, I would be a lot happier with that. Although of course ideally his "last scene" would be rewritten to make more sense.
Is there any possibility to see this happen?
2. Saskia - I went with Iorveth in TW2 (to me that path is more fun, and makes more sense, since Geralt would go with his friend Zoltan IMO). Saskia is one of my favourite characters in TW2, so I decided to cure her. I was saddened when I found out she was not present in TW3 (4 years ago, I started a thread here asking "which characters do you want to see in TW3" and Saskia was the first I mentioned). Then I was glad, when in dialogue with Philippa, that I can at least ask about Saskia.
Imagine by disappointment when Geralt asks Philippa:
"Did she manage to get herself free of your spell?"
I mean, I freaking cured her. I imported the save. So perhaps Geralt should not be asking this
Philippa says that she lost control of Saskia when the war broke out and does not know where she is.
So at least she is alive.
Still, I would like to see that line ammended to reflect what was done in TW2 - it was really jarring like this.
Ideally of course I would love to see Saskia again, as well as Villentretenmerth, in a DLC/Expansion
Then there are few more things story related that could stand improvement (Wild Hunt/Eredin etc) but those have been elaborated a lot here.