Her card looked REALLY bad but she didn't act all that bad. The priest really rub me the wrong way. I had feared everybody was killed but now I know it. Poor Vessna, she was a sweetheart. Everybody else seemed to be a waste of space. Did you noticed the gossip as you went around? everybody seemed to be cheating on everybody.
For Abigail's defence, i think was doll was meant for the sick man with the stomach ale. (does Abigail admits that she used the doll on odo, i forgot ??? but don't think so) Apart from the LHS cult thing i think she is the better choice than the villagers.
Does she play an important role then? Cause this is my second playtrough, after buying a new computer. I was a bit past halfway in act 3... so now that I restarted, wondering if I should not save her this one time?Just want to make sure I don't miss out on anything good later on by doing that. (story wise.)Solescape said:
You need her for parts of the main quest in Act 4 - I'm not sure what would happen if she died in Act II.WhiteFox said:Does she play an important role then? Cause this is my second playtrough, after buying a new computer. I was a bit past halfway in act 3... so now that I restarted, wondering if I should not save her this one time?Just want to make sure I don't miss out on anything good later on by doing that. (story wise.)WhiteFox said:
I let her live for 3 reasons:-She actualy buys all of the barghast skulls i drag into her hut with wagonloads.-I like my living shield during the Beast encounter.-I coudn't resist the urge of massacring and entire village because they would go after her.
Well I let her live because she is a naughty girlHighlordAsehujiko said:
I saved her mainly because the villagers wanted to burn her at the stake. I dont mind killing some one for a crime but I do not like the mob violence killing. There is some sort of legal system in place, at least something more then a mob wanting to burn someone because they are too stupid to think things through and not just blindly trust the rich people (because we all know that rich people do what is in everyone's best interest and never their own interest )
)So, since you're one person and unaffected by this mob mentality, the right choice is to just kill all those that are? That's justce?Ifandbut said:I saved her mainly because the villagers wanted to burn her at the stake. I dont mind killing some one for a crime but I do not like the mob violence killing. There is some sort of legal system in place, at least something more then a mob wanting to burn someone because they are too stupid to think things through and not just blindly trust the rich people (because we all know that rich people do what is in everyone's best interest and never their own interest
Shades of grey. I looked at it as the more noble option is to prevent someone from being the unfair victim of mob violence and lack of procedural justice. The opposite of that would be killing one person is better then killing a whole village. I just hate the whole "burn them at the stake" thing and did think that the peasants were being manipulated to kill a honest person by the rich/important people of their village (cause we all know that a priest will never do something wrong :Typifire said:So, since you're one person and unaffected by this mob mentality, the right choice is to just kill all those that are? That's justce?Typifire said:I saved her mainly because the villagers wanted to burn her at the stake. I dont mind killing some one for a crime but I do not like the mob violence killing. There is some sort of legal system in place, at least something more then a mob wanting to burn someone because they are too stupid to think things through and not just blindly trust the rich people (because we all know that rich people do what is in everyone's best interest and never their own interest
)
Damn right. This stems from just watching others being f'd with my whole life for just being different, and watching the same thing happen to all those I care about. Like, having their individual rights stomped to death and pissed on by these types of f'wits. As far as I'm concerned if I had Witcher power, things would change around my neck of the woods, oh yes you are godd'mn right.This includes; justice, balance and karma, and I have no qualms helping it along if at all possible, game or RL. Whether that minority is accepted by the majority as 'evil' or not does not matter if there is no equilibrium overall. If we want to point fingers, point them at ourselves, and that was my take on this whole ordeal in-game.Typifire said:So, since you're one person and unaffected by this mob mentality, the right choice is to just kill all those that are? That's justce?
*SPOILERS*
Abigail wasn't responsible for the Beast, If you listen to Alvin when Abbie gives him da potion he will say "Plow her well, show her you are a man" and "Blood-stained coin" and da first one refers to Mikul and the second refers to Odo. Also Alvin will tell at the cave that the Reverend told him to be her.But when you let da villagers burn her she will curse by the name of da lionhead spider or sth like which isn't a kind loving cult.*SPOILERS*
Connected question: have Mikul raped the girl? During the fight in the Inn one of Salamaders tells Geralt that they will do to Shani what they did to Mikul's girl and that she was a screamer. So as it Mikul or Salamandra mob?