If you let the mob kill her, she curses you in the name of the "Coram Agh Ter" a.k.a the Cult of the Lion head Spider.potl said:How do we know that Abigai is member of the LHS cult?
If you let the mob kill her, she curses you in the name of the "Coram Agh Ter" a.k.a the Cult of the Lion head Spider.potl said:How do we know that Abigai is member of the LHS cult?
Likewise, I'm just a nerd that likes to study everything about The Witcher though.potl said:Ok, i didn`t know this because I saved here every time if`ve played act 1!
Yes, I agree The arguments of the religious fanatics never convinced me to leave Abigail to the mob.Regardless of her membership of the LHS...Juuuhan said:Bad? nah...Becides Abigail is my favorite character (together with the Fisher King)Why Abigail should be saved in my opinion.- She aswell as Geralt is an outcast- Aswell as Geralt, she is decribed as powerful/dangerous but humans/people still need her, like they need witchers.- She prefer to work alone rather than with other people just as Geralt.- She helps Geralt more than those religious fundamentalism. (which in my eyes are one of the major source of evil in this world) So... always fun to slaughter them then. :evil:- And why would her religion matter? Geralt doesn't belive, he couldn't care less in religious status. So to save a woman accused by alot of bullshit from those ignorant bastards seems like the right thing to do in my eyes.
Well you can see it that way, I don't. In my opinion it's the same "one" world with consequenses. You can change the outcome but not peoples decisions.And if you look at it as a story, this game is like a story with multiple endings/happenings. However this do not rule out the fact that some people have certain opinions/religions etc etc.However i won't debate this any further, cause frankly in my opinion this is an absurd statement.fchopin said:If you take the multi parallel universe theory then that is not strictly true, just because Abigail is a member of LHS if she dies does not necessarily mean that she is also a member of LHS if she survives.We can say she is a member of LHS only if it is mentioned in the survival universe.
Which is why i disagree. Abigail was greatly hated by all humans right from the start until the wery moment she would be burned. (which were when Geralt stopped them) It's not like she right at the end joined the LHS based on the fact that she saw Geralt would leave her, or she did this earlier based on the future fact that Geralt would leave her. Becides being a witch and being hated by humans it would make sense if she had some spiders in her closet.In my eyes you could see this like a movie, a story of Geralt of Rivia. And even if the choices can be made different, all character "sheets" were already decided. Some were revealed in the way you play it and some not.So yes, in my opinion this is absurd and now, i won't continue this debate. :fchopin said:It is not an absurd statement because you can only judge a person by the experiences that are given depending on the road taken.You can change people’s decisions depending on the road taken, as an example one person could be considered a very good person if the road they took in life worked out.If they took the wrong road they could be considered bad people because life forced them to change what they considered to be good so they would survive.
Absolutely! When I saw that my first thought was "Ye Gods, woman! There are CHILDREN in that cave with you! You've probably just smashed their innocence into a thousand tiny pieces!" No wonder Alvin goes weird!Hogger49 said:...Abigail still looks less evil than the crowd--by comparison. Of course her card makes you think, "WTF did I just do? I need a shower and maybe a shot." ;D
If there are children in the cave what does that make Geralt, remember that you only see the card if Geralt says yes.So if you blame Abigail for this you have to also blame Geralt.Maerahn said:Absolutely! When I saw that my first thought was "Ye Gods, woman! There are CHILDREN in that cave with you! You've probably just smashed their innocence into a thousand tiny pieces!" No wonder Alvin goes weird!Maerahn said:...Abigail still looks less evil than the crowd--by comparison. Of course her card makes you think, "WTF did I just do? I need a shower and maybe a shot." ;D
I do not blame the developers as you have the option to choose, if you don't like her then say no.For me this is one of the best scenes in the game and i hope there are more for TW2.Evnissyen said:...Personally, I think if I had to blame anyone it would be the game developers.
Hey, I blame the developers for everything from getting me hooked on The Witcher and thus preventing me from getting any actual work done to making Geralt get me into heaps of trouble by saying really stupid things at the stupidest moments. (Though the latter doesn't apply to Act I. Those still in Act I: You'll see.)Anyway: Joking.Except that it is a little annoying when... (ch. 2 spoiler):fchopin said:I do not blame the developers as you have the option to choose, if you don't like her then say no.For me this is one of the best scenes in the game and i hope there are more for TW2.fchopin said:...Personally, I think if I had to blame anyone it would be the game developers.
Have you been in the houses in the game? Most of them have only one room.The children in the Outskirts have seen adults having sex before. And this is realistic -- throughout most of history, people didn't live in huge houses with lots of privacy. Sex might happen under the cover of darkness, so children might not have seen it, but they certainly heard it. And they certainly saw farm animals going at it. Innocence is a modern invention.Maerahn said:Absolutely! When I saw that my first thought was "Ye Gods, woman! There are CHILDREN in that cave with you! You've probably just smashed their innocence into a thousand tiny pieces!" No wonder Alvin goes weird!
As is privacy, you're right.Of course: I'm sure Maerahn was talking about the sort of... well... kinky nature of Abigail's... well... approach to sex... that is to say: what she turns into at point-of-sex... that is: What Hogger was referring to when mentioning he thinks he needs "a shower and a maybe a shot" after his interaction with Abigail.Good thing Geralt is immune to infectious diseases, eh? Eh?But I like Abigail. In both guises.Corylea said:Innocence is a modern invention.