well thats your opinion - but than again make police ai like GTA, hacking like watchdogs, car physics and customization like nfs and yeah crafting like division etc... im personally no fan of "everything is a remix" - tho i admit the crafting system is broken in CP and needs an overhaul but doing it like division where the unique parts are mostly boss drops means to separate it completely from the tech attribute and developing a stand alone system not attached to an attribute in skill builds. and I doubt they gonna do that soonish while there are clearly much other stuff to take care of first.
We both agree that it is doubtful they will "do it". The probability of the DEV using any one persons idea/mechanics is statistically low with SO many being tossed around on this forum and just in the industry alone.
But that stops no one (maybe even you) here on the forums from speculating and throwing out ideas. Any way I would not do it as you were describing what you thought I meant. I never said it should be like the division you did. I never play it as I hate multiplayer.
I made a mod for Fallout 4 designed to keep me playing the game once in a while. (I still play it about twice a month). The mod allows me to go out in the wonderful fallout world and find or buy (if merchant happen to have any) various car parts (piston, brake pads whatever) and specific materials (welding gas, epoxy, engineers tape what ever ) and use them to build sub systems. All seeded in the world at random and procedurally.
Those sub systems are used to build systems that are then used to build the car.
All build must be done at a work station which is a bare car frame and I have animations showing the character welding on the car with the song playing "one piece at a time".
The car frame slowly transforms over time into the finished car with the paint job of choice (there are about 2 dozen).
I love jumping into the game and searching for the pistons I need (finally found a few in a car in Nuka world), the steel and the welding gas from a wandering merchant, all to make an engine. The engine is one of several parts needed to build the drive system. Later that completed Drive system will be used with other systems I built to build the car!
While searching for the Pistons I always come across other items needed for the complete build so I am constantly rewarded for exploration!
I do not keep playing Fallout because my mod is so great, I love to still play it because the WORLD in there is so great. The mod just give me a good reason to keep visiting it.
THAT is how the crafting in an INTERSERING open world should be!