CDPR, stop with the 1st person (explained)

+
Pawel explains it here but when designing the game, everything is carefully crafted to 1st person
Is this the same guy that said a Police system is not necessary because Cyberpunk is not GTA? Same guy who said that there actually wasn't anything wrong with Cyberpunk at launch and it 'became cool' to hate on Cyberpunk?

I like the game a lot but I'm not going to sit here and pretend after 3 years of watching them patch up this trainwreck that at least 50% of what CDPR says is face saving bullshit. In the game, V still has left over face movements for early missions, you can see them if you answer calls in the car in the first act, you can see V talking. For calls after the first act they are not there. It is quite obvious that they had difficulty making 3rd person perspective work and pivoted to First Person. Now we can discuss whether this is better or worse, but the game was clearly originally and for the majority of its production designed from a third person perspective and was shown and advertised this way up until two years before release.
 
I'm ok with first person but I prefer third person too.
Kinda pointless with all the clothes and nice looking V, when you can't even see your character. :coolstory: (only when riding a bike)
A very common argument, I hear it a lot in these discussions. So I watched some Lets Players and streamers and the following happened in the greater majority of cases,

1. clothing is cosmetic; They pick one outfit that looks 'badass', 'cool', 'awesome' and then never change or even talk about it again. Exception when they pick something new up that they like. They'll look at the new outfit for two minutes and never mention it again, thereafter.

2. clothing has stats; People pick what has the highest numbers on it, often without caring what it looks like. Only a minority would favour looks over stats, and usually only when the difference isnt too big.

In other words, it really doesnt matter. For the few times that people want to stare at their outfit, wardrobe and photomode are more than enough.
 
us that they had difficulty making 3rd person perspective work and pivoted to First Person. Now we can discu
it is quite clear they would have difficulties making both first and third person work, because of the reasons pawel stated. This is why the game is first person and I am happy with that choice.

as for the rest of the stuff, I have no idea, I saw no hype or anything about the game up until it was released and everyone started ranting how bad it was. I tried it because I heard how awful it was, I liked it so I brought it, I have over 1k hours in it, I have about 10 in GTA 4 or whatever the latest one was. I am coming from a totally different perspective than most in my expectations and what I wanted from the game and it delivered
 
Right, but i’m not talking about changing CP77 am I? I’m talking about Orion.
I know :D
I would be strange to keep expecting something now, after the expansion and likely the last major update...


But what I say, it's as long as I don't have to "watch" a change of perspective in the middle of the game, I'm fine. It don't bother me if it's at the very beginning to introduce your character or at the end to close the story/journey.
I give another example, it's The Guardians Of The Galaxy (I don't know if you played it) which is, in theory, entirely in third person view. Great game, I like it, third person view is well done, but for strange/odd reasons, time to time, they switch you in first person view... And I don't like that either.

When I play in first person, I play in first person. when I play in third person, I play in third person... Not a (weird) mix of both :)
But that's just an opinion, mine and I don't expect everyone to share it, hence the "optional" and no matter what settings you select (depending of your preferences), the game have to stick with it. Because from experiences, both mixed together always feel weird and wrong to me (and to be honest, I don't know why studios mixe both view...)
 

"CDPR, STOP WITH THE 1ST PERSON (EXPLAINED)"​

Personally, I don't think it's wise and or desirable to "stop" offering up entirely, 1st person.

There are a lot of people that love 1st person and a lot of people that love 3rd. Think it's highly recommendable to all game dev teams around the world to at all times offer up both 1st and 3rd person perspective. It shouldn't even at any time be an issue, but more mandatory.

Todays IPs take such a long time to develop, it's simply bad marketing, unproductive and IP-worth degrading to exempt such a large part of the player-base out. I'd say, develop a game that satisfies both parties, the FPPs and the TPPs.
 
There are a lot of people that love 1st person and a lot of people that love 3rd. Think it's highly recommendable to all game dev teams around the world to at all times offer up both 1st and 3rd person perspective. It shouldn't even at any time be an issue, but more mandatory.

Todays IPs take such a long time to develop, it's simply bad marketing, unproductive and IP-worth degrading to exempt such a large part of the player-base out. I'd say, develop a game that satisfies both parties, the FPPs and the TPPs.
Yes on the paper, it's the best to do :cool:
But sadly, I don't think it's possible, or at least I didn't play for now any game which offer both perspective with The Witcher 3 / Cyberpunk level of quality (awesomeness^^).
If someone know a game which achieve that, I want to know :D
(because Bethesda's games or GTA are always pointed out, but both IP are far to stand CDPR games if you ask me^^)
 
Yes on the paper, it's the best to do :cool:
But sadly, I don't think it's possible, or at least I didn't play for now any game which offer both perspective with The Witcher 3 / Cyberpunk level of quality (awesomeness^^).
If someone know a game which achieve that, I want to know :D
(because Bethesda's games or GTA are always pointed out, but both IP are far to stand CDPR games if you ask me^^)
Well there's a game that can and has been compared to Cyberpunk for obvious reasons, that does both 3rd and 1st person perspective and is not as out there as RDR2 or GTA, The Deus Ex sequels.
 
Yes on the paper, it's the best to do :cool:
But sadly, I don't think it's possible, or at least I didn't play for now any game which offer both perspective with The Witcher 3 / Cyberpunk level of quality (awesomeness^^).
If someone know a game which achieve that, I want to know :D
(because Bethesda's games or GTA are always pointed out, but both IP are far to stand CDPR games if you ask me^^)
Personally, I think it's childishly easy for the REDS to offer up 3rd person, even at this stage.

Having played the game since forever using the 3rd person mod, it's highly noticeable the entire game's 1st person mechanic is solely based on 3rd. First the developers place an NPC, then move it in such a way so it accurately orchestrates 1st.

In order to orchestrate 3rd, they only need to place an NPC accordingly the first time. To switch back and forth freely between 1st and 3rd, they can orchestrate that seamlessly by using for instance, a teleport glitch like the modder of the NCART System did for his mod.

It's really not that difficult.
 
Well there's a game that can and has been compared to Cyberpunk for obvious reasons, that does both 3rd and 1st person perspective and is not as out there as RDR2 or GTA, The Deus Ex sequels.
Like I said, you can point out GTA or RDR2, but in my opinion, both don't achive it well...
I agree, third person view is well done, but first person view isn't. I really prefer first person view, always, since ever... but I never managed to play GTA or RDR2 in first person, because like Bethesda games, it seem wonky to me. Then cinematics are only in third person view, no matter what... So again, it just feel weird if you play in first person view...

So no, for me, Rockstar games don't mix both view very well... It's just a "third person view" game with a first person view added as they can ;)
 
But what I say, it's as long as I don't have to "watch" a change of perspective in the middle of the game, I'm fine. It don't bother me if it's at the very beginning to introduce your character or at the end to close the story/journey.

There’s also the beginning/closing of a chapter/act/section of a story, etc. Depending on how Orion’s story is structured, that’s where the opportunities for 3rd person cutscenes are potentially.

When I play in first person, I play in first person. when I play in third person, I play in third person... Not a (weird) mix of both :)

Hey I get it, we’re very much aligned on this - clearly I never suggested they change that. Hence why I think they should keep the gameplay in 1st person and continue having 1st person cinematics (when it forms an integrated part of that) as they have done. Again, I’m absolutely against disrupting any of that.

That’s why I like the addition of 3rd person cutscenes where it structurally works.

Put it this way: 3rd person cutscenes can be like bread; whereas all the 1st person stuff is the filling in between. But I’m also saying you don’t have to restrict the bread to the top and the bottom; you can have a Big Mac :coolstory:
 
There’s also the beginning/closing of a chapter/act/section of a story, etc. Depending on how Orion’s story is structured, that’s where the opportunities for 3rd person cutscenes are potentially.
That’s why I like the addition of 3rd person cutscenes where it structurally works.
If they can avoid it or better make it optional, I would prefer :)
That's pretty much my point, except at the very beginning or the very end, it would never work for me, no matter what/when/why. I just don't see how mixing both view could work in any way, it would just feel weird.

But that's just me indeed. And, again, I'm not against, as long as I'm able to completely turn off third person view :giggle:
 
If they can avoid it or better make it optional, I would prefer :)
That's pretty much my point, except at the very beginning or the very end, it would never work for me, no matter what/when/why. I just don't see how mixing both view could work in any way, it would just feel weird.

But that's just me indeed. And, again, I'm not against, as long as I'm able to completely turn off third person view :giggle:

I think that’s like assuming a meal will taste bad before you’ve even tried it ;) Or what @gregski said here
 
I think that’s like assuming a meal will taste bad before you’ve even tried it ;) Or what @gregski said here
Yeah, it's possible that I could change my mind, but I doubt. And nothing I ever played push me to think otherwise... I mean, if you don't like pinapples on pizzas, "maybe" you can change your mind one day, but doubtfull :)

True good "story - first person view" game are damn rare unlike third person view ones, that I think it will be a shame for CDPR to change their mind after such an achievement with Cyberpunk (because for me, a whole game, only in first person view from the beginning to the end of this quality, is an achievement).
 
CP2077 isn't a tactical shooter like Ghost Recon. Melee-focussed games are best in 3p. Sure CP2077 has melee but it's got more ranged play-styles than melee.

The other good reason for 3p with ranged combat is for tactical/cover-based shooters. CP2077 isn't one of those, not like the GR games are (I've got 500 hours between Wildlands & Breakpoint).

CP2077 is a broader game at its core and it doesn't go deeply enough into the gunplay, stealth, cover and (particularly) AI mechanics to benefit from 3p as a tactical shooter. Also notably, it's 100% singleplayer. 3p was crucial in GR (particularly Wildlands) because 30 guys could come for you at once and the AI is very aggressive. By comparison, the CP2077 AI is permanently set on "hang back". Numerous times recently in CP2077 I've been sure I was going to flatline because I made a mistake and enemies had a clear opportunity to rush me and overwhelm me. They didn't, in fact every time, enemies actually walked away from the fight and gave me an opportunity to regroup, heal up and get back into a stealthy posture.

CP's difficulty comes from the RPG aspects (equipment, skills, cyberware), not unforgiving tactical gameplay. IMHO 1p is a far superior choice, by a long way.
 
Numerous times recently in CP2077 I've been sure I was going to flatline because I made a mistake and enemies had a clear opportunity to rush me and overwhelm me. They didn't, in fact every time, enemies actually walked away from the fight and gave me an opportunity to regroup, heal up and get back into a stealthy posture.

That's weird. I get killed by charging melee -all- the time. Especially when my back is turned. Also murdery are the advancing heavy weapons gunners. One shredded me earlier today in fact.

2077 AI advances on me quite a lot on VH. Typically after a fun grenade barrage.

Another: last night I was clearing a particular Scav base and, under heavy fire, I sped to cover on the top or second from the top of a five story area. The Scav AI had no less than three of my attackers -climb- and jump their way up until they could shoot me. Jerks. I was just stepping around the corner with my Thermal launcher, too. That worked out poorly for everyone.

Anyway. TPP for the sequel is probably a good idea for audience satisfaction - people apparently need to see their pretty doll at all times. I do wonder if they just dress down IRL, then?

I spend an inordinate amount of time on -my- pretty doll, which is why I look cool every time I'm in my inventory (a lot), on a bike or even driving a car with regular windshields. I do wish puddles and glass were reflective off V though. That's a missed opportunity.
 
Honestly, I wouldn't mind if in CP Orion they add both 1st and 3rd person like Bethesda (see Skyrim and Fallout). Never had complaints for 1st person btw
 
Like I said, you can point out GTA or RDR2, but in my opinion, both don't achive it well...
I agree, third person view is well done, but first person view isn't. I really prefer first person view, always, since ever... but I never managed to play GTA or RDR2 in first person, because like Bethesda games, it seem wonky to me. Then cinematics are only in third person view, no matter what... So again, it just feel weird if you play in first person view...

So no, for me, Rockstar games don't mix both view very well... It's just a "third person view" game with a first person view added as they can ;)
That's why I pointed out Deus Ex. I do agree that you can't really have a mixed Third and First person perspective and do them both well. Even Deus Ex doesn't, it has essentially is a 1st person with 3rd person cover and pre scripted third person dialogues. I'm not necessarily advocating for that and ultimately it's not like I won't play a sequel if it is in first person only, but I will be kind of annoyed if you have a customisable character and no way to really view that character like in this game.

A secondary point is that probably the people who are unhappy about Cyberpunk not having a third person perspective is because the game was advertised and shown to be third person right up until shortly before its release. Had the game always been presented as first person I doubt this would be a real discussion at all, nevermind such a contentious one. Though I must say at least on this forum it does seem like nowadays most people think 1st person perspective is the best way to have done it. I don't know if I agree completely, but I certainly can agree that people believe that because the 1st person perspective in this game was very well done.
 
A secondary point is that probably the people who are unhappy about Cyberpunk not having a third person perspective is because the game was advertised and shown to be third person right up until shortly before its release.
Nope they don't, except if you consider 2018 to be "shortly before release".
In the "48 minutes gameplay showcase", it was clearly stated that the game will be in first person only, "for immersion" sake :)
Though I must say at least on this forum it does seem like nowadays most people think 1st person perspective is the best way to have done it. I don't know if I agree completely, but I certainly can agree that people believe that because the 1st person perspective in this game was very well done
Can't say if it was the "best" way and we'll never know... I prefer first person, but some of my favorite games ever are in third person, so it don't bother either.
What I know, it's in Cyberpunk, the first person is incredibly well done, better than most "first person view games" I ever played.

I mean, look at Judy scene, how could you "live" that in third person view, it's just impossible (to me).
I pointed out Judy scene, but it's the same for most cinemtics, they're incredible. For me, they bring feelings that third person will never (but it's subjective^^).
Here a cinematic with Alex in Phantom Liberty (do not watch if you didn't played Phantom Liberty, major spoiler in^^)
 
Last edited:
Top Bottom