Forums
Games
Cyberpunk 2077 Thronebreaker: The Witcher Tales GWENT®: The Witcher Card Game The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt The Witcher 2: Assassins of Kings The Witcher The Witcher Adventure Game
Jobs Store Support Log in Register
Forums - CD PROJEKT RED
Menu
Forums - CD PROJEKT RED
  • Hot Topics
  • NEWS
  • GENERAL
    SUGGESTIONS
  • STORY
    MAIN JOBS SIDE JOBS GIGS
  • GAMEPLAY
  • TECHNICAL
    PC XBOX PLAYSTATION
  • COMMUNITY
    FAN ART (THE WITCHER UNIVERSE) FAN ART (CYBERPUNK UNIVERSE) OTHER GAMES
  • RED Tracker
    The Witcher Series Cyberpunk GWENT
SUGGESTIONS
Menu

Register

Character death: the final frontier?

+
Prev
  • 1
  • …

    Go to page

  • 4
  • 5
  • 6
  • 7
  • 8
Next
First Prev 6 of 8

Go to page

Next Last
G

guidokpd

Rookie
#101
Sep 17, 2013
Well, transferring minds in and out of the net is already in the 2020 game. Granted it involves the Soulkiller program but it is possible.
 
chriswebb2020.736

chriswebb2020.736

Forum veteran
#102
Sep 17, 2013
guidokpd said:
Well, transferring minds in and out of the net is already in the 2020 game. Granted it involves the Soulkiller program but it is possible.
Click to expand...
Well, they transfered mind in, but I don't believe they ever got one out. (Except for rumours...)
 
V

vykaus

Rookie
#103
Sep 17, 2013
Interesting... How did this mind transfer work?
 
chriswebb2020.736

chriswebb2020.736

Forum veteran
#104
Sep 17, 2013
Vykaus said:
Interesting... How did this mind transfer work?
Click to expand...
I am going to assume, (for now,) that you know how Netrunning works in 2020...

The Soulkiller program, (created - mostly - by Alt Cunningham, for Arasaka,) could be commanded to attack a netrunner. It would create a copy of their consiousness within some form of secure storage device or partition within the Arasaka Mainframe. The program would then kill the netrunners body via neural feedback, essentially cooking their brain from the inside out.

Not a nice way to go...

So, when you look at it that way, transfer is an innapropriate term because you are actually copying the mind, not moving it. There could, potentially, be duplicates of the same 'personality'. Now that is messier than than an all female royal rumble in a sticky toffee pudding factory.
 
G

guidokpd

Rookie
#105
Sep 17, 2013
ChrisWebb2020 said:
I am going to assume, (for now,) that you know how Netrunning works in 2020...

The Soulkiller program, (created - mostly - by Alt Cunningham, for Arasaka,) could be commanded to attack a netrunner. It would create a copy of their consiousness within some form of secure storage device or partition within the Arasaka Mainframe. The program would then kill the netrunners body via neural feedback, essentially cooking their brain from the inside out.

Not a nice way to go...

So, when you look at it that way, transfer is an innapropriate term because you are actually copying the mind, not moving it. There could, potentially, be duplicates of the same 'personality'. Now that is messier than than an all female royal rumble in a sticky toffee pudding factory.
Click to expand...
SPOILER ALERT!! Below there is info on the adventure in the main book.

Did they change things from the main book? According to the main book Alt made the original for ITS. She remade it for Arasaka after they kidnapped her. She intended to transfer back into her body but her connection was broken.
 
chriswebb2020.736

chriswebb2020.736

Forum veteran
#106
Sep 17, 2013
guidokpd said:
SPOILER ALERT!! Below there is info on the adventure in the main book.

Did they change things from the main book? According to the main book Alt made the original for ITS. She remade it for Arasaka after they kidnapped her. She intended to transfer back into her body but her connection was broken.
Click to expand...
CP2020 said:
Soulkiller is a stationary program, locked to a partofthe system architecture. The challenge Toshiro has given her is to give itmovementthe ability to navigate the Net on it's own.

It's a subtle problem-navigation data and decision subroutines take up a huge amount of memory; the reason freeroaming programs are so limited in scope. Sou/killer already eats a lot of megabytes, to make it freerunning will take more memory than any normal computer can handle. The problem excites her professionalism even as the creation revolts her humanity.

God, they know her so well.

The original Sou/killer started as a matrix to contain artificial personalities. She'd studied the concept, worked out the parameters for creating a storage matrix. She'd been facinated and awed to discover that the same matrix could contain living engrams; transfer them from computer to body and even back again. It was immortality.

ITS had taken it from her to build a killer. And she hadn't known how to stop them.

Now Alt looks over her options. If she doesn't build Arasaka's monster, they'll torture or kill her. If she builds their horror, they'll keep her alive. But.

But once it's built, they'll put her into it.
Click to expand...
The origional design was ITS, but the really scary one was made for Arasaka.
 
D

designer5

Rookie
#107
Sep 17, 2013
thewarsend said:
Are you thick in the head or something? This game is not going to be an MMO.. That much is already been confirmed.. And you have been told that several times now..
Click to expand...
Hi you again. I have right to my wishes!

--

What comes to transferring consciousness, I don't see it happening. You guys were right to bring up copy-problem: At least the consciousness doesn't move itself automatically (unless there is some spirit world), because, something has to happen for the consciousness to move. A copy is just a copy.

So, you have two identical bodies. How do you make the first body suddenly the other one? You can't. The first one is the first one, not the copy.
 
chriswebb2020.736

chriswebb2020.736

Forum veteran
#108
Sep 17, 2013
Designer5 said:
Hi you again. I have right to my wishes!

--

What comes to transferring consciousness, I don't see it happening. You guys were right to bring up copy-problem: At least the consciousness doesn't move itself automatically (unless there is some spirit world), because, something has to happen for the consciousness to move. A copy is just a copy.

So, you have two identical bodies. How do you make the first body suddenly the other one? You can't. The first one is the first one, not the copy.
Click to expand...
You're missing a big old chunk of information.

1 - the consciousness copying process can only take place when the host interacts with the soulkiller program in a virtual environment, (such as the NET or an isolated server.)
2 - the consciousness is copied to a digital storage medium.
3 - the hosts mind is then, for want of better words, 'wiped'. It will only survive in this state on life support. Soulkiller can also 'fry' the host brain, resulting in immediate brain death. Cardiac Arrest is another option.
the copied consciousness can be tranfered into a physical host, (including the origional body or even a cloned body.) This is all rumour and conjecture however, as there are no documented instances of it occurring.
You could, theoretically, duplicate people in this manner. (Imagine an army of Sards...)

EVE online had a cloning/conciousness transfer thing going on. The idea behind it is quite nifty.

No place for it in Cyberpunk as a respawn mechanic as far as I am concerned though.
 
D

designer5

Rookie
#109
Sep 17, 2013
ChrisWebb2020 said:
You're missing a big old chunk of information.

1 - the consciousness copying process can only take place when the host interacts with the soulkiller program in a virtual environment, (such as the NET or an isolated server.)
2 - the consciousness is copied to a digital storage medium.
3 - the hosts mind is then, for want of better words, 'wiped'. It will only survive in this state on life support. Soulkiller can also 'fry' the host brain, resulting in immediate brain death. Cardiac Arrest is another option.
the copied consciousness can be tranfered into a physical host, (including the origional body or even a cloned body.) This is all rumour and conjecture however, as there are no documented instances of it occurring.
You could, theoretically, duplicate people in this manner. (Imagine an army of Sards...)

EVE online had a cloning/conciousness transfer thing going on. The idea behind it is quite nifty.

No place for it in Cyberpunk as a respawn mechanic as far as I am concerned though.
Click to expand...
I was talking more about what is / could be possible in the real life. I mean, what is consciousness? The state of the brain at a certain moment? You would need a biological clone to get a similar brain in order to be able to inject the state to the target brain. And what is a state of brain? How do you copy the position of every atom? How do you modify the atoms in the receiving body? How do you grab onto atoms inside a brain? You would need relatively massive changes, as a clone that is grown up in a pool doesn't have any proper forming happened on its brain, and there are many atoms in small bits of matter. If you don't actively train, areas of your brain will close up somewhat and further training is not that easy anymore at later age.

When you are in your current body, all of your nerves give feedback to your brain, which is you along with the rest of the body. Now, what if your nerves didn't give feedback to your brain anymore? Wouldn't you be dead? How do you make the nerves of the clone to give feedback to your brain? You can't, because you are dead and supposed to be ressurrected. The nerves of the clone will give feedback to the brain of the clone. But wait a minute. Your brain died. What are you transferring from your brain so that you continue getting feedback to your brain, which died? There is nothing. You die and that is it, unless there is some world of spirits.

You can't copy the existence itself, because if something dies, it dies.

You could speculate that just before you die your brain starts to somehow compete with the brain of the clone. You could think that your brain starts to take feedback from the nerves of the clone through the internet. But that doesn't work, because your brain really doesn't send anything away. It is just being copied. Sure you can send a virtual copy of your brain, but hey, also it is a copy, not the real thing of you. No matter what signals you send through the internet, they are all copies. You can get feedback from the internet directly to your brain, but it is only feedback. When your brain then eventually dies, your brain doesn't get anymore feedback from the internet, and with a copy out there or not, your brain - you - die.

Am I right?
 
blank_redge

blank_redge

Rookie
#110
Sep 17, 2013
ChrisWebb2020 said:
the copied consciousness can be tranfered into a physical host, (including the origional body or even a cloned body.) This is all rumour and conjecture however, as there are no documented instances of it occurring.
Click to expand...
Wait... in the canon, what about the change from Johnny Silverhand to Mr. John Silverhand? John 2.0 was a clone, rezzed by Alt, iirc.
 
chriswebb2020.736

chriswebb2020.736

Forum veteran
#111
Sep 17, 2013
blank_redge said:
Wait... in the canon, what about the change from Johnny Silverhand to Mr. John Silverhand? John 2.0 was a clone, rezzed by Alt, iirc.
Click to expand...
o_O

Which book???
I missed that entirely!
 
chriswebb2020.736

chriswebb2020.736

Forum veteran
#112
Sep 17, 2013
@ Designer5
If you talk about real life, it is normally a good idea to say so, particularly in that sort of situation.

Designer5 said:
Am I right?
Click to expand...
Presently it is not possible to 'copy' the 'essence/conciousness/personality/mind' of any creature. That is mainly because we cannot currently replicate the human brain; digitally or physically. The other major hurdle is that we do not fully understand how the brain works. Once we get that down, it will probably snowball from there. To that end, there are several labs working on it.

So, you are half right.
 
D

designer5

Rookie
#113
Sep 17, 2013
ChrisWebb2020 said:
@ Designer5
If you talk about real life, it is normally a good idea to say so, particularly in that sort of situation.

Presently it is not possible to 'copy' the 'essence/conciousness/personality/mind' of any creature. That is mainly because we cannot currently replicate the human brain; digitally or physically. The other major hurdle is that we do not fully understand how the brain works. Once we get that down, it will probably snowball from there. To that end, there are several labs working on it.

So, you are half right.
Click to expand...
No, I am still fully on the subject. It doesn't matter how many copies you make, they are all just copies. I mean, what if they make 100 copies of your brain and install them into other bodies. Will there be 100 of you alive? And how does that appear to you? You see the things that the 100 copies see? I don't think so. But if there are 100 copies there must be at least one of them that is you? But which one is it? Is it the copy number 1? No? Or if it is the copy number 1, then what are the other 99 copies?
 
chriswebb2020.736

chriswebb2020.736

Forum veteran
#114
Sep 17, 2013
Designer5 said:
No, I am still fully on the subject. It doesn't matter how many copies you make, they are all just copies. I mean, what if they make 100 copies of your brain and install them into other bodies. Will there be 100 of you alive? And how does that appear to you? You see the things that the 100 copies see? I don't think so. But if there are 100 copies there must be at least one of them that is you? But which one is it? Is it the copy number 1? No? Or if it is the copy number 1, then what are the other 99 copies?
Click to expand...
There is no answer to your question without going into religeon. I am not going there. (I may be a bit stupid sometimes, but i'm not that fucking stupid.)
 
D

designer5

Rookie
#115
Sep 17, 2013
ChrisWebb2020 said:
There is no answer to your question without going into religeon. I am not going there. (I may be a bit stupid sometimes, but i'm not that fucking stupid.)
Click to expand...
Yes, that is right. The only way out of this problem is that IF there is a spirit world, then maybe spirits can travel. But we don't know, and we don't know can technology interact with the supposed world. But ressurrecting into other body requires something more than a copy, that is for sure.

You could send droids to fight for you though. Then the droids can report to you.
 
blank_redge

blank_redge

Rookie
#116
Sep 17, 2013
ChrisWebb2020 said:
o_O

Which book???
I missed that entirely!
Click to expand...
Mmm... pretty sure it was in That Series That Wisdom Shall Not Name (that is, CyberGeneration.)
 
Sardukhar

Sardukhar

Moderator
#117
Sep 17, 2013
CyebrGen, yeah.
 
V

vykaus

Rookie
#118
Sep 17, 2013
So still, the continuation of consciousness in another medium is out of the question for the cyberpunk 2020 universe and what I was referring to earlier (ambiance thing).

@ Designer, we don't even know what consciousness is, so you can't say with certainty that some sort of continuation of the self can not be induced. Not knowing things is what science is for, not invoking absolute truths/lies based off religious or spiritual ideas. So what I'm saying is (like you also said yourself), you might be right, but you might be wrong. I just see it a little differently.
 
chriswebb2020.736

chriswebb2020.736

Forum veteran
#119
Sep 18, 2013
blank_redge said:
Mmm... pretty sure it was in That Series That Wisdom Shall Not Name (that is, CyberGeneration.)
Click to expand...
Cybergen is an alternate reality, it is not 2020 canon. (Basically the same for V.3, it is no longer deemed canon as Mike said himself that it isn't.)
 
blank_redge

blank_redge

Rookie
#120
Sep 18, 2013
ChrisWebb2020 said:
Cybergen is an alternate reality, it is not 2020 canon. (Basically the same for V.3, it is no longer deemed canon as Mike said himself that it isn't.)
Click to expand...
Oh! Well, no doubt that'll make Wis EXTREMELY happy.

And we can't have that, now can we? A happy Nomad? The idea is preposterous.

Sard, go sort that out; you're good at that kind of thing.
 
Prev
  • 1
  • …

    Go to page

  • 4
  • 5
  • 6
  • 7
  • 8
Next
First Prev 6 of 8

Go to page

Next Last
Share:
Facebook Twitter Reddit Pinterest Tumblr WhatsApp Email Link
  • English
    English Polski (Polish) Deutsch (German) Русский (Russian) Français (French) Português brasileiro (Brazilian Portuguese) Italiano (Italian) 日本語 (Japanese) Español (Spanish)

STAY CONNECTED

Facebook Twitter YouTube
CDProjekt RED
  • Contact administration
  • User agreement
  • Privacy policy
  • Cookie policy
  • Press Center
© 2018 CD PROJEKT S.A. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED

CD PROJEKT®, Cyberpunk®, Cyberpunk 2077® are registered trademarks of CD PROJEKT S.A. © 2018 CD PROJEKT S.A. All rights reserved. All other copyrights and trademarks are the property of their respective owners.

Forum software by XenForo® © 2010-2020 XenForo Ltd.