God, how I hate that shit. Sorry for the language.geluranger said:
I never
-let the mob have Abigail
-kill Adda
-kill Vincent
-betray Thaler
-give the very old wine to the stupid cheating drunkard (
)-side with either vodyanoi or the villagers, I always do the work for the lady of the lake
(because her ass puts others to shame, as geralt puts it nicely
)-kill Berengar or let him be killed by Azar
and never
-kill the trolls
-let the women burn
-let the two guys in the burnt down hospital get away
-kill the succubus
-kill the dragon
Apart from that, I think I tried virtually every possible choice.
Ouch! Now I can understand a lot of things... I AM very weird
I've played every time and I've done every choice possible at every run only for discover how CDPR resolve each situation
and because I like learn as much as possible about every NPC's blackboard. When nothing is black or white I must/need to try every grey choice.Doesn't matter if they like me or not. Oh, well, for enjoying the same story with the same final I can watch a movie or read a book.
I've played every time and I've done every choice possible at every run only for discover how CDPR resolve each situation
That is definitely one improvement of W2 over W1, is that W1 still had actual bad choices. Not save Zoltan? Let Thaler die? I can't be that callous myself. W2, aside from troll/succubus killing, which i'll never do, has no choices I wouldn't consider, because as mentioned above they are presented much better.
TW1
never
- let Abigail get lynched
- side against Thaler
- give Alvin to shani
- favor villagers or vodyanoy over each other
- kill Berengar
TW2
never
- kill speaking trolls
- side with those greedy fools in burnt mansion
- trust the succubus !
- let Adam Prangratt (arrogant bastard) go [Roche path]
- hand over Anais to Radovid
never
- let Abigail get lynched
- side against Thaler
- give Alvin to shani
- favor villagers or vodyanoy over each other
- kill Berengar
TW2
never
- kill speaking trolls
- side with those greedy fools in burnt mansion
- trust the succubus !
- let Adam Prangratt (arrogant bastard) go [Roche path]
- hand over Anais to Radovid
It's funny that you say never trust the succubus because if you give it a shot, your opinion may change.BlackLeopard said:
@ chaosapiant & M4xw0lf
I know the other result. devs have made something very special in this particular situation. you can't really decide which one is guilty for sure and there's not enough proof against both of them. (I hardly call that iron splinter a proof, it's like giving a candy to a baby)
like Cedric, when I see no strong evidence before me, I trust my feelings. in my opinion Elyas acts like a loser who has done something he didn't want to and now sees himself shackled. on the other hand, succubus behaves as a confidant schemer. she wants you to believe that everything is clear by acting cool and drawing simple conclusions. just like a true manipulator.
I know the other result. devs have made something very special in this particular situation. you can't really decide which one is guilty for sure and there's not enough proof against both of them. (I hardly call that iron splinter a proof, it's like giving a candy to a baby)
like Cedric, when I see no strong evidence before me, I trust my feelings. in my opinion Elyas acts like a loser who has done something he didn't want to and now sees himself shackled. on the other hand, succubus behaves as a confidant schemer. she wants you to believe that everything is clear by acting cool and drawing simple conclusions. just like a true manipulator.
However, Iorveth recognizes the splinter as piece of an elven sword and at the same time the succubus arguing that dead lovers are of no use to her is absolutely plausible.
In response I'd like to add the fact that I am too a friend of trolls -in context of course. I also; Never left the sexy elven women burn when choosing Iorveth's path; never slew the dragon; never fought Aryan. In contrast on my third playthrough only I got Stennis Lynched after figuring out that he was guilty. I felt better that way after discovering that he was in fact guilty of conspiring against Saskia. My thought process was that if a commoner was accused of doing so he would be thrown in prison and executed without any remorse: Since Saskia and Iorveth were fighting for equality I thought that he shoul have the same punishment. As for those two dudes, I felt it rather satisfying seeing them get what they deserved, I felt that it was the just thing to do.cmdrsilverbolt said:
I really enjoy reading about all the different actions people take haha, it's interesting to see the diversity. Another reason that this game is my favorite of all time is because the choices that you make are so consequential. If you make a mistake, you have to live with it!
Well, except for the 'quickload' button at least
In response I'd like to add the fact that I am too a friend of trolls -in context of course. I also; Never left the sexy elven women burn when choosing Iorveth's path; never slew the dragon; never fought Aryan. In contrast on my third playthrough only I got Stennis Lynched after figuring out that he was guilty. I felt better that way after discovering that he was in fact guilty of conspiring against Saskia. My thought process was that if a commoner was accused of doing so he would be thrown in prison and executed without any remorse: Since Saskia and Iorveth were fighting for equality I thought that he shoul have the same punishment. As for those two dudes, I felt it rather satisfying seeing them get what they deserved, I felt that it was the just thing to do.cmdrsilverbolt said:
I really enjoy reading about all the different actions people take haha, it's interesting to see the diversity. Another reason that this game is my favorite of all time is because the choices that you make are so consequential. If you make a mistake, you have to live with it!
Well, except for the 'quickload' button at least
I never let Henselt live on Roche's path. Wanted to have it killed, myself! (devil).
You know who has put a spell on me, there's an elven NPC in Vergen, Mona something. I think she has the same character model as Moril, except with dark hair. Yep.rethla said:
Never let Bernard Loredo live, and never will! YOU HEAR ME, YOUR ONLY FATE IS TO DIE BY MY HAND, YOU CANCEROUS TURD!
I can never bring myself to start TW2 without a TW1 save file to ensure Adda is alive.
I have trued most choices at least once due to curiosity, but I only consider it relevant if I did pick certain choice for more reasons then that.
To that end I've never...
...in TW1:
- Let Abigail be lynched.
- Killed Vincent.
- Sided against Thaler.
- Killed the Striga.
- Invited anyone but Zoltan to Shani's party.
- Sided with either the fish people or the villagers, instead resolved their conflict.
- Stayed neutral in Murky Waters between Order and Scoia'Tael.
- Let the King of the Wild Hunt have Jacques.
...in TW2:
- Killed Aryan.
- Killed the Ghost in the Insane Asylum, he always got the two men he wanted.
- Sided with Iorveth in the forest.
- Spared or helped the Trolls on both paths.
- Killed Loredo when going with Iorveth.
- Killed Adam Pangratt
- Let Roche kill Henselt.
- Let the mob lynch Stennis.
- Convinced Roche to give Anais to Natalis.
- Killed Letho.
- Killed Saskia on Roche's path.
To that end I've never...
...in TW1:
- Let Abigail be lynched.
- Killed Vincent.
- Sided against Thaler.
- Killed the Striga.
- Invited anyone but Zoltan to Shani's party.
- Sided with either the fish people or the villagers, instead resolved their conflict.
- Stayed neutral in Murky Waters between Order and Scoia'Tael.
- Let the King of the Wild Hunt have Jacques.
...in TW2:
- Killed Aryan.
- Killed the Ghost in the Insane Asylum, he always got the two men he wanted.
- Sided with Iorveth in the forest.
- Spared or helped the Trolls on both paths.
- Killed Loredo when going with Iorveth.
- Killed Adam Pangratt
- Let Roche kill Henselt.
- Let the mob lynch Stennis.
- Convinced Roche to give Anais to Natalis.
- Killed Letho.
- Killed Saskia on Roche's path.