Alright. So we get...
1.) no romance + Ciri Gone = Dandelion reacts to "fairytale ending"
2.) no romance + Ciri Gone = Dandelion reacts to "Anarietta is dead"
3.) no romance + Ciri Gone = Dandelion reacts to "jailtime ending"
4.) no romance + Ciri Gone = Dandelion reacts to "jailtime + Dettlaff dead ending" (?)
5.) no romance + Ciri Witcheress
6.) no romance + Ciri Empress
7.) Yen romance + Ciri Gone
8.) Yen romance + Ciri Witcheress
9.) Yen romance + Ciri Empress
10.) Triss romance + Ciri Gone
11.) Triss romance + Ciri Witcheress
12.) Triss romance + Ciri Empress
scenarios. Nice.
And of course there must be unique dialogues for all of them, lest there will be even more complaining how much CDPR hates their fans, right?
How about we have all of these scenarios react in extended dialogues about each of the major plot decisions the player has made during the course of vanilla+HoS+BaW? It's important, after all, to learn what Triss and the Empress think of the Johnny and Sarah's adventures in the swamp. Or just of Johnny's adventures.
I smell exponentially increasing production costs, somehow. Costs far beyond the "this seems reasonable"-point.
If that's what you want. I never suggested such a thing.
I just suggested people who romanced Triss/Yen get to see the Ciri scene as well, which is already on the disc (and, like someone said, a mod was able to allow). There is no extra cost in allowing both scenes (already on the disc) to play. I didn't suggest variations. There is nothing in Ciri's dialogue that says Geralt is a loner or would be doesn't fit with a Geralt who is with Triss/Yen, they're perfectly compatible. All you would need to is create another line of dialogue with the majordomo saying someone is in the house. You play see one scene (say Ciri)), then head back down and he says another person is in there (say Triss/Yen), and then the other scene plays. One tiny line of dialogue allowing both scenes (already on the disc) to play, unaltered.
But, if you wish to sarcastically demand all that, or overreact and misrepresent, go ahead.
---------- Updated at 08:56 PM ----------
@
killingyouguy7 Because loner ending is not "bad"... And in BaW CDPR showed that this is not something like "omg, your choice is so wrong, you failed all your life". And that maybe the reason why Ciri only in loner ending, it is better than have Dandelion (who is also Geralt's best friend btw).
I don't play the game differently to see different content. For me, Geralt has a certain personality and morals he's developed over the games, a certain character - that's Geralt. I'm not going to play against that, have him do stuff I don't think he'd do, like be a bad parent, just to see certain cutscenes. I am happy not to see the Empress stuff, or Yen stuff, or whatever. I didn't push things in those directions, so why should I see them. There is a
reason for being denied that content.
But there's
no reason you shouldn't get the Ciri scene if Geralt fell in love. There is no reason why Ciri wouldn't visit him. There is a reason why I don't see a sad dialogue about her becoming Empress, and there is a reason why you don't see her happy in the inn if you did push her to become Empress. But there is no reason she wouldn't visit a Geralt who is with Triss or Yen. It's just an arbitrary decision. There is nothing in the scene that says Geralt is a 'loner', it's perfectly compatible with a Geralt that is with Triss/Yen.
You sound like you want it to be special to 'loners', which seems selfish to me, and not everyone got that because they 'chose' it. Others get it because they just wanted to bang both Triss and Yen, which speaks volumes to their roleplaying. They probably don't even care about seeing Ciri. Yet there are people who do care about her, who roleplay hard, and who, just because Geralt fell in love with someone, get denied seeing Ciri as well. Them getting to see it as well denies you nothing. You still get your scene, your 'reward' for being a 'loner'. Why you don't want others who care for her, who fought for her just as hard for her, to have it as well, mystifies me.