Swordplay combat = Hollywood
Game is great overall but aside from player, and especially horse movement being clunky... I want to note I'm Playing on PC, using PS4 controller via InputMapper...
but..... Is it too hard to ask for a simple realistic swordplay from a game of this magnitude in 2015 ???
I understand it's a fantasy game but there's plenty of stuff for fantasy lovers, but the rest of us who want some realism, CD RED you couldn't at least have given us realistic sword combat ?? Yea I get you should throw in a few dodge/rolls or risk turning it into a buttom mash fest, I do that, but even then
can it be really that hard to build a sword combat system that can stand on it's own two legs ??
First off, once you get close with your sword it's like they motion captured only 10 sword swings and 8 of them are 360 spins.
Secondly WHY oh WHY do the quick/light sword strikes half (if not most) the the time G-Money ends up doing some bullshhhh Hollywood 360 spinorama strike instead of simple precise crisp swing/stab/cut as one would think it'd be common sense for a quick/light strike.
There are PLENTY of Medieval weapons/warfare experts in Europe, (
the re-enactors specifically) you couldn't hire one guy and motion capture some proper realistic sword hits ? Instead you slapped a motion capture suit on the accountant at the office and apparently told him the scenario was there are bees buzzing all around, kill them with your sword.
Trying to put together a swordfight via something swift and precise is impossible, not just because of the reasons I listed above, but also because of these reasons you're stuck in these long drawn out animations for too long, this isn't my opinion these things I'm talking about are facts there's no way around it. I'm wondering if patches or better yet future mods will be able to fix the combat ??
Summing this up would be like a Mixed Martial Arts fighter going into a fight, and almost exclusively using his roundhouse kicks/knees and spinning elbows/fists for the majority of his strikes, does that sound ridiculous to anyone ?