It's your opinion and probably that of many playersRDR2 for what it is its a masterpiece.
Cyberpunk 2077 for what it is is just a mediocre half made, rushed game.
For what it is, for me it's not a masterpiece, it's just "really good" but the gameplay is atrocious (like in all RockStar's games since GTA3).
I have more fun to play on Cyberpunk (my game's stats speak themself...). But it's just a matters of tast