Good enough to pull me away from the Appalachian wasteland of Fallout 76
The City is nailed, the world is detailed (even with some areas not being detailed actually), but mostly it works and mostly if you don't try and break the fabric, then the illusion sets in. Driving around the city with a bike is the best way I get immersed, the music, the ride and city all work in favor and create the mixture of 'This is great', but stopping for a sec or doing a side activity is when that fabric is too thin to not accidentally tear.
I don't know if it's that I've just been waiting for a world that looks and feels like this (easily convinced by aesthetics, lol), or what, but I feel so immersed in this game, in a way that you get immersed in a movie just from watching.
The world just feels so compelling, there are so many tantalizing details that draw you in. Even if it is ultimately empty, my imagination fills up half the details, because my brain seems to be convinced that this is a consistent, real-enough experience; to me, this is the magic of videogames. I'm grateful for Cyberpunk 2077 for taking me back to that place of imagination, for bringing me that sensation I've been missing for so long, that I first fell in love with on the train ride into Black Mesa.