We're criticizing a story, any sort of practical criticism is legitimate.Claims of legitimate criticism that are on their face abusive, such as "criminal lack of characterization", are not legitimate criticism at all. They only serve to show that such criticism is disrespectful and may safely be ignored. If you want your criticisms to be taken seriously, do not make them in such a bitter, badgering tone.
Moderator direction to keep criticism respectful, humane, and constructive should not result in dispute but result in other posters reviewing their criticisms more carefully to make them more constructive and less abusive.
True communication occurs only in an atmosphere of mutual respect, not one of self-proclaimed superiority and entitlement.
Perhaps not respectful towards CDPR personal and they may ignore our comments, but nor did we expect they'll relate to it as is now, did we?
Now, as for the 'entitlement' well, we were promised a game with a great story and conclusion to the series and got neither, I think it's rather legitimate for us to complain about it