If you leave the rabid dogs, they turn into Barghests; I'm glad that doesn't happen in OUR world!dieruhe said:
LOL.Yea I mean, whenever I see a huge dog covered in flames I just wanna romp around the yard with him till he gets tired then chill out with him next to the campfire or something. ;DLyc said:And how many times did the beast attack Geralt, until Geralt pulled his sword out - Zero. Granted it attacked the peasants - but they deserved it.Oh sure, you could try and claim it made the Barghests attack, but notice how every time the beast appears and howls the Barghests attack a few moments later. It was probably trying to warn Geralt of an impending attack. And the circle of fires was its attempt to keep the Reverend, Odo, et al from attacking the witcher.But nooooo, just because its a big dog covered in flames people assume its okay to kill it. Did you kill Vincent as well? He turned into a big dog after all ;D
i finished the quest without killing any dogs.heres how. look in ppls barrels wardrobes ect for dogtallow all the guy wants is dog tallow he doesnt care how you get it.and your a dog killer!!! scum!!
I killed Vincent because he was a dog lol. No seriously though I killed the dogs because of the tallow, mostly because I was too dumb and lazy to look in the barrels in the housing around the villages.Lyc said:And how many times did the beast attack Geralt, until Geralt pulled his sword out - Zero. Granted it attacked the peasants - but they deserved it.
In roleplaying terms, that's actually cheating, because the Gravedigger says something about wanting to get rid of stray dogs because they're rabid, lice-ridden or something.MichelleB12 said:
That's what the contract says. But then when you take him the dog tallow, he says that it's useful for the coffins he's making; it's like he's forgotten why he said he wanted it. Must be all that dwarven liquor.Planewalker said:In roleplaying terms, that's actually cheating, because the Gravedigger says something about wanting to get rid of stray dogs because they're rabid, lice-ridden or something.Planewalker said:
Probably a bit of both. The city authorities charged him with the task of getting rid of the stray dog problem, so he subcontracted the job to a witcher and used the tallow to improve his coffins.Corylea said:That's what the contract says. But then when you take him the dog tallow, he says that it's useful for the coffins he's making; it's like he's forgotten why he said he wanted it. Must be all that dwarven liquor.
Definately a doggy killer. they are in the way and they give 5 points grease to top it off you get experience and gold by doing the quest. goes a lot quicker then going through all the barrels and houses too if you ask me. I do tend to use a lot of the oils, really appreciate the cinfrid oil against a horde of humanoids as a lot of them end up dancing in pain instead of hacking in to geralt. The spectre oil isn;t bad either as those damn wraiths tend to scream a lot so if I can get them down with one attack less then thats a bonus imo.but yeah doggy killer me. don;t like dogs anyway so not a hard thing to do.
I did the quest... but overall I don't like killing dogs and wolves in games (or in real life). So I left the other pups alone. I like the sniffing they do when you go near them.
It shouldn't gnaw at your conscience when you kill wolves. It's self defense and they attack Geralt even if he does nothing to harm them. And bear in mind... wolves give beast liver which contains Rubedo & Rebis which exists only in 3 ingredients (beast liver, lunar shards and green mold).
That is true.PetraSilie said:
I merely thought it as a sort of reality issue... aren't wolves afraid of humans (and Witchers) and could more likely run away? It's just a point of view actually and up to the developers to decide if wolves are aggressive in the game. Then again... they are in packs in the game so it must be like they're defending their territory.Can't do it. I adore dogs in real life and (un)fortunately everyone brings something of themselves into a game. Perhaps if I can bring myself to playing an evil bastard I can but I doubt it.
But do you find enough to fulfill the gravedigger's quest? I loaded an old A2 save and Geralt... he finished the quest and still has 4 (four ) dog tallows in his bag.Does that mean he found so many for free or did I kill 4 dogs though the quest was finished :whatthe: I do this quest because Geralt needs the money (and xp) but I don't kill dogs for fun... or was I too greedy because dog tallow is base for 5 ingredients oil.
) dog tallows in his bag.Does that mean he found so many for free or did I kill 4 dogs though the quest was finished :whatthe: I do this quest because Geralt needs the money (and xp) but I don't kill dogs for fun... or was I too greedy because dog tallow is base for 5 ingredients oil.If dogs carry beast liver players have their sights much more on doggies... which arent't really beasts. To harvest beast liver go to the swamp and take them from wolves at the druids grove or the cave in the south