Out of a 1-10 rating.
Start from 10.
Difficulty: Easy mode. I will admit I'm not the most skilled gamer. In fact I'm probably not skilled at all with controllers or keyboards when it comes to gaming. I rely heavily on "easy" modes in games. I think it's great to have mulitiple difficulty settings for everyone to enjoy. I had such a hard time with TW1 that I didn't get more than 1/4 into the game before I quit. Same thing happened in TW2. Many probably disagree with me, but I define "easy" differently than some gaming companies do. I got to the Kayran in TW2, that was my quitting point. Three days of no success is enough for me. I find my character dies a lot, it's frustrating and unenjoyable. This brings my 10 to a 9. That's generous I think.
Quests: Lots of quests and when direction is given, all is well. Spending hours and hours with no direction is another game killer. I like constant progress. I don't mind if stuff takes time, as long as I feel like I'm progressing and having fun. Running around trying desperately to get clue as to what I'm supposed to do is not fun. Having to go online and do research for hours is not fun. I found I had to make choices due to lack of direction. This brings my 9 to 8. Still being generous.
System requirements: Either have to have a decent PC or an Xbox console. I have a decent PC with a horrible graphics card and I don't own an Xbox. I own a handful of PC games that aren't anywhere near as demanding. I've only had one online game that was almost as demanding with if not better graphics, just as good. Final Fantasy 14. I had to mess with the settings for hours and ended up running the resolution to 800x600 to play the game. Graphics were still decent, but it's sad that so much has to be done to get this game to play. I'm not cheap, I'm disabled and can't really afford to spend much money on stuff. This brings my 8 to a 7.5 which I think is fair.
Storyline: Is great. I wish I could have progressed to see how it goes. I never got to finish TW1 either. My 7.5 to an 8.
Graphics/Artwork: Beautiful. Even though I didn't get to really experience the best TW2 has to offer, what I saw I loved. My 8 to 8.5.
Gameplay: When I wasn't being beat up, which was most of the time, the sword fighting was fun to watch. Easier to use than TW1 if I remember right. Using signs was fun too. I had a hard time with boxing matches, much easier in TW1 and the armwrestling was hard too, but those don't really matter in the storyline, I think. Overall gameplay is good most of the time. 8.5 to 9.
My overall score of TW2 is a 9. I probably will trade it in towards another game because it's too hard for me, but I like the storyline, artwork and uniqueness. I know most people will disagree with me. This is my own opinion. CDProjekt is loved for a reason. I wish them well. I just wish they could make easy mode "easy", have solid direction in their quests and make their games available to PS3 too.