Actually, the OP compares the two in his post. So, I think some comparison is allowed, if it is justified for the argument. And it does seem that Yen-fans versus non-Yen fans disagree on her character because she is different to Triss, according to non-Yen fans.No. What is silly is that Triss is even in this conversation. This is supposed to be a Yen thread, not a Triss vs. Yen thread. There are plenty of other threads for that.
---------- Updated at 04:00 PM ----------
I don't think it is a bad thing. I prefer it actually. The events of the previous games still matter. It's not a standalone. And, I don't se TW as a typical RPG like Skyrim. Yes, you can roleplay, but as Geralt. So, you have to roleplay with all the baggage and history of his in mind.Yep thats very clear TW3 is more a sequel to the books than the games but I don't think thats a good thing
As a result the previous games are basically rendered meaningless and it damages roleplaying