While I answered no and no I think its closer to pay to progress rather than pay to win. We need to understand that a totally fresh player (even if he has an idea from the Witcher 3 Gwent) is not familiar with strategies (early pass, bleeding, discarding etc.) or even strategic ladder climbing and keg opening (when I started a 2nd account for fun I first focused opening WOTW ST kegs). Also a player who started in March or April for example was hit by another disadvantage within a month when the new starter packs came out and suddenly he has to face much stronger cards. So if after 10 ranks comes to a point that his win/lose ratio becomes very imbalanced its understandable to see it as P2W and it doesn't matter if it is true or not. It is primarily a skill game and secondary luck and while you can win with the old starter pack I doubt it you have acquired the skills so early. So it would be nice not to judge new players and their opinions through a seasoned player prism