Lmao the boxing matches

[Rivian2805]

Jesus christ this is so atrociously bad its insane.

People hitting you, although they get "parried". People hitting you even though they miss you on screen. I have no idea how they managed to screw up a minigame that they had pretty much down in witcher 2 and 3.

Also the driving in chars in first person is trash too, You can not see the road.

 

[Myajha]

I have no idea how they managed to screw up a minigame

There I fixed it for you. If you can tell me one thing they didn't screw up in the name of trying to make profit, I'd be surprised. This is just one of the more glaring ones where the managers said "it's good enough, move on to something else, the longer we do this, the lower our bottom line" instead of saying "it's broken? Go ahead and fix it, we want a quality game."

 

[SidTheUndying]

Shooting too. It saddens me so many devs don't comprehend LOS (Line Of Sight).

 

[Kingler13]

It basically is a microcosm of melee combat. Don't bother with parry because half the time it doesn't trigger and there isn't any feedback when it does and some attack animations are hard-coded so dodge or stay out of range is the only option. The only "fluid" option is attack and move and stay ludicrously "out of range" to avoid the opponent and then get right on top of them to connect a blow.

 

[Tokotoko1911]

Go make a game yourself

 

[RecceJack]

I like their intentions & approach.. but yeah..

What irks me the most as somebody who has been training boxing for 20 years come a few months from now and trains some women & kids in different MMA aspects... it's more blatant now to see with the rise in everybody wanting to have boxing matches like the youtubers and slam dunk champions... when I go into photo mode and cycle through to the fighting stance.... I can't begin to explain how absolutely insane this drives me, because it's so in your face with all the amateur-celebs...

when I start with people, I tape their elbows in and we just focus for weeks on footwork and body movement... When I see the bird wings, the elbows all up and out to the side... I lose my mind.. in the photomode, V has this stance.. I've overlooked a lot of different things that are slightly off.. but I just can not over look this..


IDK nothing about making a video game or the technology and the computer stuff that goes into all that.. but if you can put them motion suits on keanu reeves... can't you just go to a reputable gym or some of these retired boxing or MMA legends and get them to do the motion for this stuff? Same thing with certain aspects of combat with tactics and weapon manipulation... In USA, every other ex tier 1 & 2 operator is a firearms & tactics instructor... I don't understand the disconnect here, but again I don't understand how all the game making stuff works.. Maybe I'm thinking of things that aren't doable IDK..

I've always wondered.. Couldn't they just bring in 4-6 guys for the motion suits, set up various scenarios and rooms and stuff and then have them provide a half dozen different possibilities & approaches per scenario and then have the games generate accordingly? Both with firearms & tactics and hand to hand combat.. then everything looks appropriate, or at least close enough..

again.. IDK anything about how this stuff works but in my mind this seems like something that makes sense.

 

[Tokotoko1911]

I like their intentions & approach.. but yeah..

What irks me the most as somebody who has been training boxing for 20 years come a few months from now and trains some women & kids in different MMA aspects... it's more blatant now to see with the rise in everybody wanting to have boxing matches like the youtubers and slam dunk champions... when I go into photo mode and cycle through to the fighting stance.... I can't begin to explain how absolutely insane this drives me, because it's so in your face with all the amateur-celebs...

when I start with people, I tape their elbows in and we just focus for weeks on footwork and body movement... When I see the bird wings, the elbows all up and out to the side... I lose my mind.. in the photomode, V has this stance.. I've overlooked a lot of different things that are slightly off.. but I just can not over look this..


IDK nothing about making a video game or the technology and the computer stuff that goes into all that.. but if you can put them motion suits on keanu reeves... can't you just go to a reputable gym or some of these retired boxing or MMA legends and get them to do the motion for this stuff? Same thing with certain aspects of combat with tactics and weapon manipulation... In USA, every other ex tier 1 & 2 operator is a firearms & tactics instructor... I don't understand the disconnect here, but again I don't understand how all the game making stuff works.. Maybe I'm thinking of things that aren't doable IDK..

I've always wondered.. Couldn't they just bring in 4-6 guys for the motion suits, set up various scenarios and rooms and stuff and then have them provide a half dozen different possibilities & approaches per scenario and then have the games generate accordingly? Both with firearms & tactics and hand to hand combat.. then everything looks appropriate, or at least close enough..

again.. IDK anything about how this stuff works but in my mind this seems like something that makes sense.

It's not a boxing game

 

[SidTheUndying]

Go make a game yourself

I have in the past. Mine worked.

Go form an intelligent response. (consider this deleted, reason: feeding troll and rude.)

Post automatically merged: Dec 28, 2020

It's not a fucking boxing game

Yet pretending to have fucking boxing IN the game.

Edit

 

[RecceJack]

It's not a fucking boxing game

You just learn this?

 

[Tokotoko1911]

 

[Rhyzur]

I just use a Katana for those. Legendary baseball bat works, too.

 

[Attidd]

Go make a game yourself

Haha you sound like you're an angry employee for CDPR

 

[KundIGWENT]

well i used double jump to dodge the punches and some how when i'm in the air the opponent still mange to hit me
and hey even the reward is trash after beating every opponent