Nah, I'd say concentrating on swordmanship with minimal sign usage is a perfectly viable way to play DM. Getting through enemies' defences without signs isn't difficult.
Can you defeat groups of enemies +10 levels above you with swords? With signs it seems too easy for me. How do you get through their defences with swords without getting flanked? I am aware you can dodge, but groups of enemies will surround you, and the spinning attack doesn't go through blocks.
Well.. similar to how it was previously, specializing in signs seems to be completely trivializing 99% of the encounters. Who needs sword damage when you can keep aarding everyone over and over and poking them once once they're down? Or just burn them to a crisp if they won't lie down? I'm playing on the penultim difficulty and I hardly ever need to use the swords for anything other than finishing people who are already burning or waiting for me to poke them once.
Meanwhile even the lowly lvl 5 bandit is adept at parrying every single one of your fast swings. I don't know guys, I'm 18 points in the magic tree and if I keep investing in it at this rate Geralt is sure to rename to White Wizard. Signs are supposed to complement swords, but I can easily just annihilate everyone without swinging them once. Is Death March for me or does the last difficulty just expect you to exploit sings?
Well.. similar to how it was previously, specializing in signs seems to be completely trivializing 99% of the encounters. Who needs sword damage when you can keep aarding everyone over and over and poking them once once they're down? Or just burn them to a crisp if they won't lie down? I'm playing on the penultim difficulty and I hardly ever need to use the swords for anything other than finishing people who are already burning or waiting for me to poke them once.
Meanwhile even the lowly lvl 5 bandit is adept at parrying every single one of your fast swings. I don't know guys, I'm 18 points in the magic tree and if I keep investing in it at this rate Geralt is sure to rename to White Wizard. Signs are supposed to complement swords, but I can easily just annihilate everyone without swinging them once. Is Death March for me or does the last difficulty just expect you to exploit sings?
First off, how you play is your choice. If you choose to Aard everything and instant kill them all the time, or just burn everything, then that's how you chose to play the game. Personally, I invested most of my points in the sign tree, and I use the griffin set. BUT, I don't just spam my signs. I also have 5/5 fast attack, and a bit of bombs in alchemy. I utilize everything this game has to offer, from crossbow bolts to bombs, signs, sword attacks, and counter attacks.
I Quen before the fight, dodge and try to group them up, Igni them all up, dodge back, throw an Enhanced Grapeshot, and slice up the stragglers. I could just dodge-igni-dodge-igni, but that's boring.
Try to mix up your combat, benefit from staggering opponents with signs, and then hacking them up. You'd enjoy it alot more.
Note though, I play on Death March.