Main character: Voiced or non-voiced?

+

Do you want a voiced main protagonist ?


  • Total voters
    39
I would say zero chance of non-voiced, especially given how well they did the facial mimics in TW3. Cinematic presentation is clearly a priority for them, and they definitely wouldn't do TPP with a silent protag in this day and age. That 'works' in Origins only because it's a clear throwback to traditional CRPGs.
 
Voiced and similiar to Witcher 3 :) that`s PERFECT and I can see the character I have made for this game interacting with others in a cinematic presentation. (It has some character creation aspects, right?)
 
For me voiced.

There's just this weird disconnect in modern rpgs where all the npc's are voiced yet your character is silent, it seems rather...weird.

Ever since Mass Effect came out it's been harder and harder to go back to silent protags for me.

I just hope if there is a voiced protag that they have a couple different voices rather then one, so you can at least choose what type of voice you want. Like how Dragon Age: Inquisition allowed you to pick from two voices (A more more gruff voice and then a more proper/posh voice).
 
I like me a voiced character. My only problem with CP2077 having a protagonist being voiced is that you can build the character from ground up. So do you just have 3 different voice packs per gender? Where do you draw the line about how much money you're willing to put into the main character's voice by hiring multiple VAs. This is why I'm not a game designer and what not. Haha, these decisions would be too tough for me.
 
I find text dialogs somewhat immersion breaking, so I'd definitely prefer all characters to be voiced.
 
The supposedly massive scope of CP2077 and the player character being a blank slate usually would strongly suggest non-voiced, but if CDPR feels up to the challenge...
It's an insane amount of work though, both for the writers and the voice actors.

10 roles the player character can assume means that you'd have to account for 10 times the same dialogue including role-specific and situational variations plus special lines according to the player character's social skills (Intimidation, Persuasion, Seduction, etc) or stats/attributes (Low Intelligence for example).
And that's not even a bunch of different voice sets for both female and male characters taken into account.

It's when fully voiced severely limits and puts constrictions on the amount of dialogue options that I'd rather have a non-voiced player character with a wide selection of dialogue options to choose from instead.

Remember Fallout 4.



You don't want to go there.
 
The supposedly massive scope of CP2077 and the player character being a blank slate usually would strongly suggest non-voiced, but if CDPR feels up to the challenge...
It's an insane amount of work though, both for the writers and the voice actors.

10 roles the player character can assume means that you'd have to account for 10 times the same dialogue including role-specific and situational variations plus special lines according to the player character's social skills (Intimidation, Persuasion, Seduction, etc) or stats/attributes (Low Intelligence for example).
And that's not even a bunch of different voice sets for both female and male characters taken into account.

It's when fully voiced severely limits and puts constrictions on the amount of dialogue options that I'd rather have a non-voiced player character with a wide selection of dialogue options to choose from instead.

Remember Fallout 4.



You don't want to go there.

Exactly why I suggested the Pillars of Eternity/ Baldur's gate style. Mix of both depending on importance to main plot. Facilitates the addition of mod quests if CDPR want to go that way along with reducing the massive cost of so many actors. But I suppose some people might see that as lazy or distracting depending on their experience with older styled RPG's.
 
The supposedly massive scope of CP2077 and the player character being a blank slate usually would strongly suggest non-voiced, but if CDPR feels up to the challenge...
It's an insane amount of work though, both for the writers and the voice actors.

10 roles the player character can assume means that you'd have to account for 10 times the same dialogue including role-specific and situational variations plus special lines according to the player character's social skills (Intimidation, Persuasion, Seduction, etc) or stats/attributes (Low Intelligence for example).
And that's not even a bunch of different voice sets for both female and male characters taken into account.

It's when fully voiced severely limits and puts constrictions on the amount of dialogue options that I'd rather have a non-voiced player character with a wide selection of dialogue options to choose from instead.

Remember Fallout 4.

I wouldn't assume that all 9 roles will be options for the player.

Also, I think Fallout 4 is not a fair comparison. IIRC that was Bethesda's first game with a voiced protagonist. CDPR already has lots of experience in how it works. Granted since it's likely to be a player generated PC to an extent, CDPR will have to account for many more variables, but I would still expect it to be more like Witcher 3 (with more dialogue options) than Fallout 4. I am expecting only two voiced protagonists (male & female). It will be an insane amount of work, but keep in mind that CDPR's will have almost twice the amount of staff (270 to 500) as they did during TW3 by the time CP2077 is close to release.
 
10 roles the player character can assume means that you'd have to account for 10 times the same dialogue including role-specific and situational variations plus special lines according to the player character's social skills (Intimidation, Persuasion, Seduction, etc) or stats/attributes (Low Intelligence for example).
those are special cases, even if they are frequent. and not all skills may be used in every situation.

Remember Fallout 4.
fallout 4 was more a design problem I think. most of the time they recorded 4 versions of the same option and an answer to each of them, then just carried the conversation straight ahead without even knowing the answer. the amount of duplication and unnecessary dialog is crazy. if they didn't force themselves to always have 4 options, and if they actually wanted to make quests involve choices, they could have done a lot more. I don't think voice acting cost was the primary problem there.
a lot of the times in the witcher you only get two options, yet nobody complains, because those are two different options and they make sense.
 
fallout 4 was more a design problem I think. most of the time they recorded 4 versions of the same option and an answer to each of them, then just carried the conversation straight ahead without even knowing the answer. the amount of duplication and unnecessary dialog is crazy. if they didn't force themselves to always have 4 options, and if they actually wanted to make quests involve choices, they could have done a lot more.
...
a lot of the times in the witcher you only get two options, yet nobody complains, because those are two different options and they make sense.
Yeah I noticed that in Fallout 4 ... you ALWAYS had 4 options, even when they didn't make sense because they were to few or to many.
 
if they make it just like t2 and tw3 it will be alright, simple options and the characters explain and give more information
 
Depends on how much of the player character is already established and characterized.

If you create the PC completely from scratch, as it looks to be the case with Cyberpunk being a PnP RPG at its core, I wouldn't mind the common approach of only voicing primary or key dialogue while leaving secondary, more specific and elaborate options further down the dialogue tree non-voiced.

Basically the best of both worlds.
 
There is too many negatives to a voiced protagonist. Dev, after dev after dev have admitted that you will ALWAYS be limited if you have a VO voiced protagonist. Think about it. You have ONE person reading a ton of lines from a script. Of course they have to keep it simple one liners or they would never leave the recording booth. on top of that once something is recorded, they are stuck with it and that means they cannot change that scene or dialog in the game unless they want to record it all again (remember, they are still recording a ton of dialog). The person has no idea of what the scene is like, so they are guessing how the person should respond when talking too. On top of all this, every damn VO has the same damn personality. This alpha male kickass persona(geralt, shephard, adam jenson..etc), which really only fits the kickass roles, but other roles will not mesh well. If I choose to play a nethacker, I want to play a geek in meatspace, but a god in cyberspace, if a rockerboy I want play either as a hellion rebel or peacemaker, a teckie is a person who gets excited about the latest tech and gear and talks about it, a corp should act and be sleezy..etc. I just can't see them creating any variation to the personality. I want to ROLEPLAY, i want a ton of dialog to talk about, I want branching dialog, I want dialog to open and close based on my stats/choices. Most of all I want an actual conversation that goes back and forth that actually feels meaningful. Flavor text makes a huge difference in the game. Sure, it might not change the outcome, but it at least makes YOUR character feels like how you imagine it. Didn't they say we would choose our sex? So that is two people reading the same ton of scrips. Again, that will lock down the character in a straitjacket. I really do not want a fixed character, I want to create MY character like you can in the books.

my thing is, if they went to all this trouble getting a TRPG game which allows for you to create any type of character you want, what would be the point of it, if all you are going to do is create a premade character? Defeats the whole point of the source material in my mind.
 
Just a little tidbit, but when doing voice over work it's not merely reading a line. You are given context and emotion, that's why you can have some great emotional voice-over work in games. They don't have to "guess" at it as it's generally presented to them the context of the lines they are saying and the feeling that the director is looking for. It's not like they simply locked you in a room with lines and give you no direction or context for your lines or the inflections they are looking for.

Also you can bring people back to re-record lines, but this will cost you more $$$ usually.
 
Well, if they would choose a proper voice actor/actress then I'd be fully for voiced protagonist, but I'm not really sure right now. Though I would miss hearing some voice speaking (like in the first Dragon Age game for example).

I want a good voice actress like Jennifer Hale. She was so good as fem!Shepard.
 
Like I said, I would rather not because it would greatly limit your choices. With that said, there is some amazing work with synthetic voices being done with googles deepmind. Check this paper out and the examples it show, not just voices, but music too. https://deepmind.com/blog/wavenet-generative-model-raw-audio/ One day, we might not need voice actors at all, the writers can write whatever they want and a computer will read the line however they want on the fly.
 
I think we live in times when non voiced games are not acceptable anymore. I mean... I know that it worked in some games in the past, but now? I couldn't get through Pillars of Eternity, Divinity: Orginial Sin and Wasteland 2 just because of that. I dont mind reading - I love reading books, but I do mind and actually hate reading games. I mean, for me It's kind of like watching silent movie nowadays but with a shitload of text instead single lines.
 
I think it would be acceptable to go for the hybrid method a few people here suggested already.
Non-voiced for one half and voiced for the other half which would include all the dialogue lines crucial to the progress of the story, that have to be delivered in a specific manner to trigger the desired emotional impact, etc.

Have the dialogue options for the non-voiced lines formatted differently (italic, smaller or special font, coloring) from the ones for the voiced lines and you have successfully evaded the (potential) pitfall of indistinguishability where voiced ends and non-voiced starts as well.

I do think that CD Projekt REd is one of the few RPG developers that could actually pull it off and make the hybrid method acceptable (again), even among those too lazy to read. It would just need to be presented in a captivating and interesting way to keep people hooked.

Completely voiced I think would actually do a lot more bad than good. It (almost) always results in a limited and shallow "less than a hand's breadth" RPG experience and only so much of choice and consequence (not to mention reactivity) as the spoken lines allow for.
Which completely goes against the type of RPGs where the player creates her or his own character (often modelled after her or himself) and expects to be able to leave as many of her or his personal marks on the story as possible, by, among other things, dynamically steering the narrative through a wide array of (vastly) different dialogue options producing just as many (vastly) different outcomes.

The already mentioned Fallout 4 is the prime warning example for how it should not be done.
 
Yeah, thing is - I don't think CDP Red is going to make a game like fallout (if so - I might accept non-voiced protagonist). I'm almost sure the game will be more like they're previous titles - story driven game, but this time with semi-fixed charachter (kinda like Shepard in ME). Also I wouldn't be warried about "limitted and shallow" dialogues. They handled that almost perfectly in TW3, so I can't see why wouldn't they in Cyberpunk.
 
Top Bottom