Make non-lethal takedown matter (gameplay-wise)

[poosh]

There are a few quests where non-lethal takedowns matter, but, otherwise, there is no difference between stealth-killing and non-lethal takedowns.

I suggest the following:

• Non-lethal takedowns give more stealth XP than the lethal ones.
• Enemies can wake up after a non-lethal takedown. Wake up time depends on the player's stealth level and maybe some perks.
• After the wake-up, the NPC raises an alert and resumes the fight unless put into a container.
• If put into a container, the NPC cannot escape. However, he/she still can produce sounds after the wake-up, alerting others nearby.
• Clearing the area gives the player bonus XP for every enemy left alive ("pacifist XP"). NPCs that wake up after the area gets cleared become non-hostile (run away).
• [OPTIONAL] Introduce a perk into the stealth skill tree to display the enemy wake-up clock on the HUD.

So there will be the choice between easy stealth-killing or more challenging non-lethal takedowns for extra XP. Basically, the first non-lethal takedown starts a countdown to clear the area before the alarm gets raised.

 

[eternal_streetkid]

I really like all of these ideas. Meaningful non-lethal mechanics, a la Metal Gear Solid.
Here's hoping most (if not all) of these ideas will find their way into the game!

 

[AJdaTruth]

Yes, use some of Metal Gear's stealth mechanics and game design.. Because, why would I worry about choosing a 'Non-Lethal' or 'Kill' takedown or enemy defeat.. when an enemy is 'knocked out' by a non-lethal defeat or takedown when they will not 'wake up' if I'm discovered, the body is discovered or an alarm goes off while trying to be stealthy.