Wow long read. But yeah must say I agree with the majority of the posts. I also got the "left out in the cold feeling" when the game placed me back at the castle, and I was like wtf. Now yeah sure they could of just ended it like many other game out there that the credits role and you have the option to start the game over with the bonus of keeping armor and abilities, but they did this anyway buy adding new game+ But the fact is that this game has two expansions that take place within the timeline of the main game makes me think some effort should of been made to have the main npc charecter in the post game world, without it affecting the game world state.
There really have been some great ideas for the inclusion of npc main charecter said in the various posts before mine, and like many have said they don't have to reflect a dramatic change to the world state.
i basically would have liked to have seen something like:
(based on ramance interactions) Yen in Gerald's bedroom at the castle/Triss . . .somewhere getting ready to leave for Kovir, and the option for Gerald to return to them and possibly ask about the brand placed on him by O Dimm, instead of having the dialog on the boat (and some of us don't get that particular dialog if we have finished the main campaign, for obvious reasons). The option to play dandelion at Gwent in his tavern (or Zoltan ). Nothing big lol
Anyway, I thought Keira was supposed to be gone, but she is out on like a cliff/ledge behind a locked door at Kaer Morhen. I had to do some serious jump glitch in to get over to her, you can still buy stuff from her, and once there I could not get back in the castle. Dunno if they fixed this but she was still there in patch1.11 have not checked again since, lol because there is nothing to go back to Kaer Morhen for.