1.1 - Welcome to the Hellmouth (B)
1.2 - The Harvest (B)
1.3 - Witch (C)
1.7 - Angel (A)
1.9 - Puppet Show (B)
1.10 - Nightmares (A)
1.11 - Out of Sight, Out of Mind (C)
1.12 - Prophesy Girl (A)
2.1 - When She was Bad (C)
2.3 - School Hard (A)
2.6 - Halloween (A)
2.7 - Lie to Me (B)
2.8 - The Dark Age (B)
2.9 - What's My Line, Pt. 1 (B)
2.10 - What's My Line, Pt. 2 (B)
2.13 - Surprise (A)
2.14 - Innocense (A)
2.15 - Phases (c)
2.16 - Bewitched, Bewildered and Bothered (B)
2.17 - Passion (A)
2.19 - I was Made to Love You (B)
2.21 - Becoming, Pt. 1 (A)
2.22 - Becoming, Pt. 2 (A)
3.1 - Anne (C)
3.3 - Faith, Hope & Trick (B)
3.6 - Band Candy (A)
3.7 - Revelations (C)
3.8 - Lover's Walk (B)
3.9 - The Wish (A)
3.10 - Amends (B)
3.12 - Helpless (B)
3.13 - The Zeppo (A)
3.14 - Bad Girls (B)
3.15 - Consequences (B)
3.16 - Doppelgangland (A)
3.17 - Enemies (B)
3.18 - Earshot (B)
3.19 - Choices (A)
3.20 - The Prom (A)
3.21 - Graduation Day, Pt. 1 (A)
3.22 - Graduation Day, Pt. 2 (A)
4.1 - The Freshman (C)
4.3 - The Harsh Light of Day (B)
4.4 - Fear, Itself (A)
4.6 - Wild at Heart (B)
4.7 - The Initiative (B)
4.8 - Pangs (C)
4.9 - Something Blue (B)
4.10 - Hush (A)
4.12 - A New Man (A)
4.13 - The I in Team (D)
4.14 - Goodbye Iowa (D)
4.15 - This Year's Girl (A)
4.16 - Who Are You (A)
4.19 - New Moon Rising (B)
4.20 - The Yoko Factor (B)
4.21 - Primeval (B)
4.22 - Restless (A)
5.2 - Real Me (C)
5.3 - The Replacement (B)
5.5 - No Place Like Home (C)
5.7 - Fool for Love (A)
5.8 - Shadow (D)
5.10 - Into the Woods (D)
5.12 - Checkpoint (B)
5.13 - Blood Ties (C)
5.14 - Crush (B)
5.15 - I Was Made to Love You (D)
5.16 - The Body (A)
5.18 - Intervention (A)
5.19 - Tough Love (B)
5.20 - Spiral (C)
5.21 - The Weight of the World (C)
5.22 - The GIft (A)
6.1 - Bargaining, Pt. 1 (C)
6.2 - Bargaining, Pt. 2 (C)
6.3 - Afterlife (B)
6.5 - Life Serial (C)
6.7 - Once More, With Feeling (A)
6.8 - Tabula Rasa (A)
6.10 - Wrecked (D)
6.11 - Gone (D)
6.13 - Dead Things (D)
6.14 - Older and Far Away (C)
6.16 - Hells Bells (C)
6.17 - Normal Again (B)
6.18 - Entropy (B)
6.19 - Seeing Red (B)
6.20 - Villains (A)
6.21 - Two to Go (B)
6.22 - Grave (A)
7.1 - Lessons (C)
7.2 - Beneath You (C)
7.3 - Same Time, Same Place (C)
7.5 - Selfless (A)
7.7 - Conversations with Dead People (A)
7.8 - Sleeper (B)
7.9 - Never Leave Me (B)
7.10 - Bring on the Night (C)
7.11 - Showtime (C)
7.15 - Get it Done (C)
7.16 - Storyteller (A)
7.17 - Lies My Parents Told Me (A)
7.18 - Dirty Girls (B)
7.19 - Empty Places (C)
7.20 - Touched (B)
7.21 - End of Days (B)
7.22 - Chosen (A)
GRADING KEY - A = Essential Viewing; B = Very Good, but not Great; C = Good but Flawed in Some Way; D = Would be Skippable, but Plot Important