New CG Cinematic for The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt Shows Geralt “Killing Monsters”

+
KnightofPhoenix said:
Well all they need is to have Charles Dance's voice and it will be umf for sure.

Yup, I think Emhyr's appearance in the main release trailer is obligatory!
 
Wichat said:
What's lke the nilfgaarian sound?
The soldiers in the English trailer talk with a heavy accent. They don't do that in the Polish trailer though. I like the latter more, sounds less fake.
 
Thank you.

About some 700 posts before I asked:
Wichat said:
Oh! Waht about this dirty hair which softly collides with clothes before returning to its site?

Much better than TW2 or only a little better?
 
All right, a lot has been said here, and as I mentioned before, there are several possible takes on this trailer, and all of them (be that moral dilemma itself, the absence of one, or a narrative) are problematic. Still, all of this could probably be explained away, or just discarded as not so significant.

But recently I read the most disturbing opinion from some posters who actually agree with the majority. Their worry is about not the trailer itself, but a message behind this trailer.

Sure, it is AAA trailer, well done from a technical stand point. Nobody disputes this. Also we all can agree that trailers are not made just for kicks, they have purpose, they have an intended audience, and they communicate a certain, well-defined, and thought-out message. I assume without any proof or argument that people in CDPR know what they are doing, that the trailer reflects their vision, and they actually took their time with it, thinking it through from every angle, especially from the perspective of intended message, and intended audience.

After E3 CDPR would probably want to capitalize on their success, and because TW3 is a AAA-title, it is highly desirable to reach a wider audience, which would include Bioware and Bethesda fans.

Keep in mind that quite a few people who posted their opinions and reviews of TW2, did not like the core concept of TW2, and did not like any ending, because it did not give them any satisfaction. They did not feel that they won, they felt bad either route they took. Some complained that they liked to play ‘good guys’, and, for example, working as a hit-man for a rapist king was not their idea of a hero they wanted to play. Compare with Bioware system of morality, with clear paragon/renegade routs, where even if a choice should be made, practically always there is the best solution, and often even bad guys recognize the error of their way and praise protagonist for his wisdom.

The intended audience is obviously wider than the fans of previous games, or those who read the books. This trailer is a promotion aimed at new gamers as well. So it should present the game well, and not mislead them.

Also, such trailers are not done to present something minor or insignificant. They should present the idea behind the game, a showcase, for interested people, to further inform their opinions. The behavior and situations should be indicative and representative, not some flukes.

cmdrsilverbolt said:
Yeah, I think there was something to her look; like I said, I would have distrusted her in any other scenario.

Now, what do we see in the trailer? Judging by the quote, which is a fair assessment, this trailer uses a sort of visual rhetoric, a situation so clear-cut that probably 95% of the viewers did not see ANY moral dilemma at all. Yes, we can talk about some situations in the books, but the thing is that the majority did not read Sapkowski’s books at all. They judge by what they see. What we see is a self-righteous Geralt makes a preachy comment (I would expect the same position from real life priests) about evil, and jumps to the rescue of a damsel in distress, who is about to be brutalized by invading soldiers even visually presented with extreme bias. Geralt is presented as a clear-cut paragon, a white knight Geralt, who does not just act, but also clearly states his new-found creed. Keep in mind that CDPR could have told any story, or presented any situation in a trailer, but they consciously choose this one.

Now, what purpose does this rather unexpected take on Geralt serve? What message is communicated to possible buyers? Does CDPR go after Bioware and Bethesda fans who do not find satisfaction in the choices we had in TW2, who want to have an option to play as a good guy, and who always want an obviously good (or right) solution? If this trailer is indicative of this, we will have a major change in concept. TW2 was so great exactly because very often there was no right choice, and it was impossible to have a happy ending. If in TW3 we will always have a ‘paragon’ route, TW3 will loose any uniqueness, and, for me at least, most of its appeal. Sure, it will cater to more gamers, and bring home more money, but would you be on board with this change? I know I won’t.

It is even worse if the trailer is misleading. Let’s say it is part of the game, and we’ll have bad consequences. Gamers who want to be ‘good’ will be extremely unhappy. So what, they should have let this girl to be brutalized? You can’t really tell them – well, if you check the trailer frame by frame, you’ll see a smirk on her face,… It is about the same as to tell a person who signed very bad credit card agreement that he should have read a very small font at the bottom of the third page.

I don’t know, guys. I see so many problems with this trailer whatever perspective I take, that it is not funny anymore. Now my real worry is that this trailer indicates a possible major break with the concept of real, hard, none is good, damned if you do, damned if you don’t, choice, to a concept when there will be always an obviously good or right choice present, and the rest just an artificial coloring. Otherwise I simply do not see any point in presenting Geralt in this kind of situation at all. Again, this trailer should faithfully represent the game, and if the presentation of Geralt, who openly denounces any choice of a lesser evil, is the faithful indication of a route you can take in the game (otherwise why a hell to use this visual rhetoric and visual clichés at all in order to illicit immediate psychological response), it is damn horrible.

Probably it is time to start praying to Holly Yennefer Mother of Ciri that CDPR would never go that far in their bid for a wider audience, and Geralt, despite this trailer, will be still perfectly capable and willing to choose a lesser evil (which one is lesser will be for players to decide), in no situation of choice there will be an obviously right or good decision, and there won’t be any clear-cut, uncontroversial happy endings.
 
@vivaxardas: Agreed. A good post


Although I'm not so sure about the smirk. Resolution's not good enough to be sure, but the girl has a bit puffy lips and prominent cheekbones, so that might create the expression from afar. At least it looks like this for me.
 
I cannot agree. We don't know if it's a trailer, a cut-scene, an intro, a post choice scene... etc... etc. I IMO cannot judge TW3 since those 2:45. I've read the books and all I can see is another Geralt's act, no a White Knight at all, and I agree Geralt's choice till no further information tells me what really happens and why. Meanwhile, I will go on with my open mind about any else option.
 

Agent_Blue

Guest
Hi vivaxardas,

Good to hear from you.

I've been saying some of the same things, namely that, apparently, the trailer is not really indicative of the morally ambiguous crossroads we are supposed to be meeting in the TW3. However, it seems to me a second trailer might help put things into context. We're still a long way from release so there's every chance they'll put out additional material. Whether or not it will clarify the situation or even revolve around the same cast of characters remains to be seen.

So, while I agree with many of your points and have stood by them myself, I still feel there's a degree of open-endedness to the trailer that seems to hint at CDProjekt's intentions of elaborating on it further along the line or even in the game itself.

This trailer is just begging for a twist.
 
vivaxardas said:
Also, such trailers are not done to present something minor or insignificant. They should present the idea behind the game, a showcase, for interested people, to further inform their opinions. The behavior and situations should be indicative and representative, not some flukes.
You're not wrong, but let's keep in mind that this is one in a line of trailers which we will see, and the other ones could tell us a whole different story of Geralt. It's inadvisable to predict a pattern of any behavior from one single incident, that's why it would be inaccurate to say that CDP is going to go down a certain route for sure from one trailer.

What we see is a self-righteous Geralt makes a preachy comment (I would expect the same position from real life priests) about evil, and jumps to the rescue of a damsel in distress, who is about to be brutalized by invading soldiers even visually presented with extreme bias. Geralt is presented as a clear-cut paragon, a white knight Geralt, who does not just act, but also clearly states his new-found creed. Keep in mind that CDPR could have told any story, or presented any situation in a trailer, but they consciously choose this one.
I completely agree with you on the point that they deliberately put Geralt in a situation where there was only one clear path. I can only make guesses about why they made this trailer, but I believe that there was only one path in it.

It doesn't matter who or what the woman was, or what she did, it also doesn't matter that she was a woman- there was only one path for Geralt in that case, or at least that's what I believe.

That said, I find it rather disturbing that people would consider helping someone being brutalized as "white knighting".

Now, what purpose does this rather unexpected take on Geralt serve? What message is communicated to possible buyers? Does CDPR go after Bioware and Bethesda fans who do not find satisfaction in the choices we had in TW2, who want to have an option to play as a good guy, and who always want an obviously good (or right) solution? If this trailer is indicative of this, we will have a major change in concept. TW2 was so great exactly because very often there was no right choice, and it was impossible to have a happy ending. If in TW3 we will always have a ‘paragon’ route, TW3 will loose any uniqueness, and, for me at least, most of its appeal. Sure, it will cater to more gamers, and bring home more money, but would you be on board with this change? I know I won’t.
Maybe we're reading too much into this, maybe it was just about showing this cool guy being a badass. I find this statement as really biased and contrary to the evidence- you are forgetting the Leshen quest which indicates that there will be morally-ambiguous scenarios in the game.

It is even worse if the trailer is misleading. Let’s say it is part of the game, and we’ll have bad consequences. Gamers who want to be ‘good’ will be extremely unhappy. So what, they should have let this girl to be brutalized? You can’t really tell them – well, if you check the trailer frame by frame, you’ll see a smirk on her face,… It is about the same as to tell a person who signed very bad credit card agreement that he should have read a very small font at the bottom of the third page.
I don't see how the trailer is misleading- it tells a clear message that Geralt acts after he assesses a situation, and that despite being a witcher committed to neutrality, he can act in ways which contradict that.

I don’t know, guys. I see so many problems with this trailer whatever perspective I take, that it is not funny anymore. Now my real worry is that this trailer indicates a possible major break with the concept of real, hard, none is good, damned if you do, damned if you don’t, choice, to a concept when there will be always an obviously good or right choice present, and the rest just an artificial coloring. Otherwise I simply do not see any point in presenting Geralt in this kind of situation at all. Again, this trailer should faithfully represent the game, and if the presentation of Geralt, who openly denounces any choice of a lesser evil, is the faithful indication of a route you can take in the game (otherwise why a hell to use this visual rhetoric and visual clichés at all in order to illicit immediate psychological response), it is damn horrible.
Who knows, maybe you're right- it's possible that the Nilfgaardian empire might be portrayed wholly as something to oppose (not that we should think so from just one trailer). People have mentioned that the Devs compared it to the Third Reich, and that's not something in which you can see a whole lot of grey.

But maybe I'm wrong, and there's plenty to expect from Nilfgaard which we wouldn't otherwise. A shade of grey implies redeeming qualities, and if we expect Geralt to have a chance to side with the Nilfs, then they (or Emhry) will need to portray something which people can consider a redeeming quality.

Moreover, the problem I see with siding with Nilfgaard is Ciri- if she's in the game, and she's a part of the plot, then there can't be any choice for Geralt to pick any side but hers. Or else, siding with the Emperor would mean handing over Ciri. That's something to consider, I think.

Probably it is time to start praying to Holly Yennefer Mother of Ciri that CDPR would never go that far in their bid for a wider audience, and Geralt, despite this trailer, will be still perfectly capable and willing to choose a lesser evil (which one is lesser will be for players to decide), in no situation of choice there will be an obviously right or good decision, and there won’t be any clear-cut, uncontroversial happy endings.
I think you're implying that you would like a chance to side/work for Nilfgaard, and I hope you get it, but it needs to make sense in the overall plot with respect to all the characters included, otherwise including this option for the sake of including would be quite fake.

But seriously, it's simply ridiculous to say that the game will lack moral-ambiguity or shades of grey just from this trailer. This makes me think that the memory span of the average gamer is about two weeks at best :D/>/>
 
It is not about siding with anybody I am concerned with. This trailer should be indicative of Geralt's character, presents his major motto (as long as it is presented at all), and a representative situation from the game. Here he is presented as clear paragon, and he does not just act, he also clearly states his view on the matters of evil. If this is misleading, and no obviously right or good route will be possible, what sense does it make to state this new principle in a promotional trailer? People would claim that this trailer is misleading, but in this case the writers did not really do a good job, did they? Some new potential players will be mislead, and I don't see it as good.

In Leshen case it is obviously possible to make another way to resolve it, in Bioware fashion, when the girl is alive, and Leshen is dead. You'll just need to look for it a little harder. So it does not really demonstrate that it will be a hard choice. We sure should know more, but for me it is a good enough reason to worry about this matter.
 

Agent_Blue

Guest
vivaxardas said:
It is not siding with anybody I am concerned with. This trailer should be indicative of Geralt's character, presents his major motto (as long as it is presented at all), and a representative situation from the game. Here he is presented as clear paragon, and he does not just act, he also clearly states his view on the matters of evil. If this is misleading, and no obviously right or good route will be possible, what sense does it make to state this now principle in a promotional trailer? People would claim that this trailer is misleading, but in this case the writers did not really do a good job, didn't they? Some new potential players will be mislead, and I don't see it as good.

In Leshen case it is obviously possible to make another way to resolve it, in Bioware fashion, when the girl is alive, an Leshen is dead. You'll just need to look for it a little harder. So it does not really demonstrate that it will be a hard choice. We sure should know more, but for me it is a good enough reason to worry about this matter.

Geralt's soliloquy presents a highly questionable take on Evil, but that's not the point.
Is it in-character?

Moreover, it seems to me the soliloquy is above all a fictional device, so we get to actually watch Geralt's thought process in action, eventually leading up to his decision to step in. It's like a dark self pep talk. Essentially, because there is no real dilemma as to which side stands for evil, CDProjekt had to come up with a rhetorical device which shows and accentuates his hesitation on whether or not to intervene, however flimsy or overblown this hesitation might appear.

I seriously doubt Geralt will live up to this motto. If indeed all evil is essentially the same, if it all bears the same nature, will Geralt be stepping in every single occasion he finds evil at work?
 
You are over-simplifying the Leshen case, but whatever.

The trailer does portray Geralt's character, it just doesn't portray the kind of Geralt that you would play. People have mentioned that he steps up to protect others from being attacked senselessly in the books, is he being a paragon then as well?

I also don't think Geralt saving that woman absolves her of what she might have done- the important thing is that Geralt acted based on a personal feeling, that he didn't want to walk away from someone being brutalized. Honestly, I think he understood on some level that there is plenty of grey in the world despite him feeling black/white at that moment; we can see this in the instance of him not drawing his sword or using igni on the soldiers. I think he gave them a chance to run, but he also knew that they wouldn't- it was an inevitable shit storm.

People will judge things for themselves when they play the game, but I don't think the trailer is misleading at all.

I seriously doubt Geralt will live up to this motto. If indeed all evil is the same, if essentially it all bears the same nature, will Geralt be stepping in every single occasion he sees evil at work?
He didn't step in to stop evil, he stepped in stop something he did not like.

Let me rephrase this- he stepped in this time because he didn't want this act to occur, and maybe he thought it was evil (which I think it was so I'm calling it that), so yes I think Geralt would step in to stop whatever he thinks he should; at least, that's my understanding of the character from books and related sources.
 
How is Geraly portraied as a CLEAR paragon in the trailer, when he rides away a fair distance, while the girl already has the rope on her neck?

It's when the soldiers decide to torture the girl instead of hanging her that Geralt stops and turns back. Not that clear paragon to me.
 
AgentBlue said:
Geralt's soliloquy presents a highly questionable take on Evil, but that's not the point.
Is it in-character?

For me obviously it is not in character. Worry is whether CDPR decided to change his character into something else. As intended for new players as well, for a wider audience, who have no idea what Geralt's character is, who may never played any TW games, or read the books, this trailer is either extremely misleading, or represents a change in a core concept. Neither of it is good. In any case, future will tell.

AgentBlue said:
You are over-simplifying the Leshen case, but whatever.


He didn't step in to stop evil, he stepped in stop something he did not like.

I am not over-simplifying anything. It is perfectly possible to add a third choice, where everything ends up well, to ANY situation. Adding more is not over-simplification.

And his preachy proclamation about evil is just what, empty sounds?
 

Agent_Blue

Guest
vivaxardas said:
For me obviously it is not in character. Worry is whether CDPR decided to change his character into something else. As intended for new players as well, for a wider audience, who have no idea what Geralt's character is, who may never played any TW games, or read the books, this trailer is either extremely misleading, or represents a change in a core concept. Neither of it is good. In any case, future will tell.

Again, I think it's a purposefully overblown piece of rhetoric meant to elevate what's not a substantial hesitation to begin with. By framing it as this grand debate on the nature of Evil the soliloquy bestows upon it substance and resonance it otherwise wouldn't have.


It sort of works.
 

Agent_Blue

Guest
vivaxardas said:
And his preachy proclamation about evil is just what, empty sounds?

Not entirely, but for the most part, I guess so. That creed is both idealist and absolutist - it's unlivable by.

Again, can you imagine Geralt, or anyone for that matter, living up to that motto?
 
People are clearly forgetting the very clear cut scenarios of TW1 and TW2.

They've always been a part of the series and there is nothing un-witchery about them. Because what's great about the series, is that it doesn't try too hard to make everything ambiguous, which would just be on the level of a fan fiction written by some teenager who thinks he's complex.

And the Geralt they portrayed has always been the same Geralt, it's not a sudden alien take. That's the guy who agreed with zoltan when he said "the greatest evil is moral relativity." They did not give us the option in either game to play a moral relativist. We always play someone who strives to do what he thinks is good (and even in the difficult choices, in the flashbacks he tries to find a way to make it sound good), who's just in a too complicated world to always give him clear-cut scenarios.
 
Top Bottom