Let's face it, mostly (not all the time), people that like Oblivion actually like it because of mods they have added to make the game better, the AI better, add more quests, creatures, etc. People that don't like Oblivion are talking about vanilla Oblivion and are thinking about their first gaming moments with the game. All games suffer against Oblivion because they are never going to get the 10,000 mods that Oblivion has got! I still play Oblivion after about 2 years, and it's because of mods like MMM and Lore Creatures and Francesco's additional weapons. These mods, plus many others, totally change the game, and in a way, it's not Oblivion anymore. Whatever this highly modded game is, it's that that I am playing, not Oblivion, per sae. The Witcher, along with Arx Fatalis and Two Worlds and others all suffer in a way because of this way that Oblivion can be heavily modded. When we talk about Witcher - we are talking about Witcher, with Oblivion, you can never be quite sure because of all these mods you may have added to the game!