So I ended up getting Alan Wake and I'm playing it with my wife.
The game is fun, engaging and extremely cinematic. It does remind me of Max Payne, especially with his loud thinking/narrating and the little extras (like the TV shows instead of the Batboy comics).
A few complaints though: why are the controls so weird? Or is it because I'm using K+M? The camera positioning is pretty bad too, and especially annoying when a shadow guy creeps up unexpectedly behind you. I feel like poor old Alan is too stiff and slow, but then again this is part of the appeal since he is just an unfit writer in (and I quote) "a tweed jacket".
It's entertaining though, and well worth the price *I* set

Kind of wished instead of so much repetitive and dull combat they had more puzzles and problem solving. More of an adventure than a third person shooter. But then again, this *was* an XBox game...