Thats not a plot hole. Former writer, Jan Bartkowicz, explained it on Bioware forums few days ago. He said this:Dona said:Geralt's remark about Ves being a liar,
Babli said:Thats not a plot hole. Former writer, Jan Bartkowicz, explained it on Bioware forums few days ago. He said this:
"Geralts says Ves lied in regard to her telling Roche that Henselt just let her go."
"I defeated you once and I'm totally going to do it again even though I could kill you right now instead of wasting time telling you I'm going to do it in the future. So c ya later, lol!"Dona said:And yes, the scenario in which Roche wins is the worst x_x
But didn't she say to them both "I can still smell that swine on me!" I thought it told pretty clearly what happened to her .Dona said:Thats not a plot hole. Former writer, Jan Bartkowicz, explained it on Bioware forums few days ago. He said this:
"Geralts says Ves lied in regard to her telling Roche that Henselt just let her go."
That could just slipped her tongue. She never actually admitted it to them. Doesnt matter, it is now cleared outCreeperX said:But didn't she say to them both "I can still smell that swine on me!" I thought it told pretty clearly what happened to her .
I understood it like that, but many players didn't. It's nice of Jan to have explained that - on a forum that has nothing to do with the Witcher - but in my opinion, that is one thing that shouldn't have been left unclear. The remark made it sound like she was lying about Dethmold, the Henselt situation was pretty clear (he grabs her in the flashback).Babli said:Thats not a plot hole. Former writer, Jan Bartkowicz, explained it on Bioware forums few days ago. He said this:
"Geralts says Ves lied in regard to her telling Roche that Henselt just let her go."
Biggerhorn is mentioned a few times on Iorveth's path, apparently he is someone who apparently saw Saskia kill the dragon. Someone tells you to "go and see him" if you want to hear the story. But he doesn't exist in the game. That is why I said it's not really a plot hole, I imagine his story would've been just a few funny lines of dialogue.Babli said:btw whos Biggerhord?, i really cant remeber that name....
Iorveth: "I don't regret that it's you..."Babli said:"I defeated you once and I'm totally going to do it again even though I could kill you right now instead of wasting time telling you I'm going to do it in the future. So c ya later, lol!"
*5 minutes later*
"Geraaaalt! That bastard Iorveth got away!"
Me: *facepalm*
Hahaha! XD. That was pretty much what I thought too. Iorveth had that stupid expression on his face and said it in such a dreamy voice and all.Dona said:Iorveth: "I don't regret that it's you..."
Me: "Now kiss!"
So much wtf.
What's wrong with the letter?Dona said:It is not the only plothole left unfilled - there's Margot's letter
It remains in your inventory forever, Iorveth never receives it :/ I know it doesn't really serve any other purpose other than letting the player know Margot's been working for Iorveth and that Malena was indeed doing some shady business (although Dmitri says it, too) but a simple "here's the letter" "thanks" would suffice.KnightofPhoenix said:What's wrong with the letter?
Dona said:I understood it like that, but many players didn't. It's nice of Jan to have explained that - on a forum that has nothing to do with the Witcher - but in my opinion, that is one thing that shouldn't have been left unclear. The remark made it sound like she was lying about Dethmold, the Henselt situation was pretty clear (he grabs her in the flashback).
Biggerhorn is mentioned a few times on Iorveth's path, apparently he is someone who apparently saw Saskia kill the dragon. Someone tells you to "go and see him" if you want to hear the story. But he doesn't exist in the game. That is why I said it's not really a plot hole, I imagine his story would've been just a few funny lines of dialogue.
Iorveth: "I don't regret that it's you..."
Me: "Now kiss!"
So much wtf.
I think he's speaking about her letter to Iorveth you can find in her room. I thought it was useful, maybe hand it to Roche or Loredo but no it just stuck in my inventory doing nothingLoboLawNM said:What is wrong with Margot's letter? You mean her suicide note, right? I thought it was pretty clear...am I missing something? I thought the scene added a lot--it was a dark little aside; a window into the desparate and sad life of a woman trying to live the best she can in the cold world of the witcher.