Well maybe its not RPG, but did someone here play the Legacy Of Kain series? For example Soul Reaver or Defiance? It is a story based game (althoug the story was made up for the game) and I think it has many things, which the Witcher should have also.First of all - story and atmosphere. For me this elements are the most critical. This things are the ones that keep you playing the game, just to find out what happens next, what will happen, and that let you enjoy all the little things in the game, that actually makes you like some characters and hate others. Legacy of Kain for me is the leader in this. Music and voice talent - You can see some of the LOK outtakes (i recommend you do, they are fun) on youtube. The voices were perfectly chosen for the characters, and I mean it. And the music ofcourse - first class. The music in Witcher IMO seems to be great as well! Thats a very good sign! I very liked the begining of the graphics presentation, when they showed us the sunrise. It composed with the music perfectly.Characters - I think I dont have to write anything about this. Interesting characters make you enjoy the game so much better.