That's fair enough and I might have "sounded" more harsh than I meant to be in my original reply.Different strokes.
For me, just being able to bomb down Night City at night on a Kusanagi, music blaring, in first person, is worth the price of admission alone. And instantly became one of my favorite gaming experiences thanks to growing up oogling Akira and Blade Runner. That and honestly, the game just feels like Witcher 3 with cars, guns, and cyberpunk. The gameplay loops are almost exactly the same. The world is almost just as empty of things to do (Gwent at least made up for this). The NPC's are just as flat.
None of these are excuses for the city being the way it is. Simply that I'm fine with those above things, and didn't have much expectation for this game other than getting that. Though there does seem to be a lack of more meaty side quests. They exist, but there's fewer of them, and if they do have meat, they just seem to suddenly screech to a halt.
Graphics, at least on PC, also elevates the game for me. Usually I'm not much of a graphics snob, but this game is damn beautiful most of the time.
However, I totally get mileage varies WILDLY here. Because the game is buggy as hell, and because there's stuff obviously censored and/or flat out missing. Not to mention optimization issues on PC for a lot of people, and the inexcusable console releases. So I will agree with you on the fact the game is definitely not where it should be, at all. And my saying it's 'amazing' is very literally only my opinion.
The city is gorgeous, no way about it, especially on console, probably the most beautiful city in a game, ever. I love it, truly the city of my dreams.
At first I also enjoyed just cruising around in my car looking at it, but as soon as I stepped out I noticed the faults. It's a damn shame nothing is interactive. Game feels more like an Ubisoft open world or Borderlands. Hell, Ubisoft worlds usually have more meaningful things to do than this. The AI being terrible is also a huge problem for me, and breaks immersion constantly.
For me the game is a 7/10 at the moment. I hope it can become a 10/10 with some more work put into it. After I complete my current playthrough I will probably put it down for a few months and come back to it after a bunch of patches, DLC and an expansion have been released for it. I've gotten my 60 dollars worth, no doubt about it. I just wish it was the same game they presented in that 2018 demo, the amount of cut content depresses me.