I guess the way people were praising TW3, calling it "game of the decade" etc... made it seem like CDPR were above the rest. Plus their marketing style for CP2077 which was reminiscent of that of Rockstar's, gave that greater-than-life vibe, that only a few devs can match (can only think of Santa Monica studios).
Honestly, playing the game you could see the potential, but it's just not even close to being there, and I doubt it ever will be. So we are stuck here with a story of what could have
The last game I was this hyped for was probably God Of War 3, I have probably seen this trailer like a hundred times