Forums
Games
Cyberpunk 2077 Thronebreaker: The Witcher Tales GWENT®: The Witcher Card Game The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt The Witcher 2: Assassins of Kings The Witcher The Witcher Adventure Game
Jobs Store Support Log in Register
Forums - CD PROJEKT RED
Menu
Forums - CD PROJEKT RED
  • Hot Topics
  • NEWS
  • GENERAL
    THE WITCHER ADVENTURE GAME
  • STORY
    THE WITCHER THE WITCHER 2 THE WITCHER 3 THE WITCHER TALES
  • GAMEPLAY
    THE WITCHER THE WITCHER 2 THE WITCHER 3 MODS (THE WITCHER) MODS (THE WITCHER 2) MODS (THE WITCHER 3)
  • TECHNICAL
    THE WITCHER THE WITCHER 2 (PC) THE WITCHER 2 (XBOX) THE WITCHER 3 (PC) THE WITCHER 3 (PLAYSTATION) THE WITCHER 3 (XBOX) THE WITCHER 3 (SWITCH)
  • COMMUNITY
    FAN ART (THE WITCHER UNIVERSE) FAN ART (CYBERPUNK UNIVERSE) OTHER GAMES
  • RED Tracker
    The Witcher Series Cyberpunk GWENT
THE WITCHER ADVENTURE GAME
Menu

Register

(SPOILERS) Which Choices Are You Planning To Use For Your First Witcher 3 Playthrough?

+
Prev
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • 6
  • 7
Next
First Prev 4 of 7

Go to page

Next Last
U

username_3689055

Rookie
#61
Sep 2, 2013
I haven't played the first Witcher yet, though I intend to eventually. My first TW3 run will probably be based off these TW2 choices.

- Spare Aryan - Prevent Nilfgaard gaining an ally in the La Valletes
- Help Roche - Prevent the needless massacre in Flotsam
- Side with Roche
- Spare Henselt - Anarchy only benefits Nilfgaard's conquest.
- Expose Kimbolt and Maraval - Whoever rules Temeria should know who's loyal to who.
- Give Anais to Radovid - The united Temerian-Redanian power is the best (I feel) for opposing Nilfgaard.
- Spare Sile - She'll probably be out there opposing Nilfgaard in her own way.
- Spare Saskia - She's a good person looking out for the common people.
- Kill Letho - Who's to say the Emperor won't have him do more tasks?
 
U

username_3497665

Rookie
#62
Sep 2, 2013
I intend to import my first playthrough choices that were based on instinct and after replaying different paths still feel closest to me. They might not be the smartest, most rational or leading to a potentially better outcome in TW2, but they are MY choices I'm somehow personally attached to.

Spare Aryan
Help Iorveth
Side with Iorveth (Loredo alive)
Spare Stennis
Kill Cynthia (a little bit of cheating, first I killed Adalbert only, but changed my mind - still given that it's EE I can't even call it 'my first playthrough')
Save Saskia
Spare Sheala

Aaand I don't know what to do with Letho. First time I let him go and last time I played the path I wanted to make my 'canon' to be imported (basically repeating initial choices, I just had to because I'd lost the saves) I decided to kill him because I figured I owed it to Roche somehow. (Playing Iorveth path always leaves me with this sense of guilt and debt, as well as massive gratitude towards Roche after the visit in Nilfgaardian camp!)

The thing is, I don't really have much internal conviction about killing Letho (especially that him saving Triss might be considered a new debt...), so I even tried rationalising the choice by remembering Cynthia's warning ('don't trust Letho') :p/>
Still, given that she's not the most trustworthy person and that neither Iorveth nor Roche insist on going after Letho in the epilogue on their respective paths (which I find questionable, but I guess we have to assume they've got bigger and more important matters and goals than revenge...), it's ok to let Letho go.
So I'm still on the fence about that.
 
R

Rauter

Forum regular
#63
Nov 17, 2013
I'm going to import savegames from my first playthrough.

Choose Triss: She can (in theory) protect Alvin better than Shani.
Spare Vincent, Berengar and Adda: Vincent is a good man and I didn't want to leave him to become monster.
I forgive Berengar his treason.
Adda is *****, but I rather remove a curse than kill a monster.
Stay neutral: I'm not interested in war.
Choose to fight King of the Wild Hunt: I'm not interested to be his "champion of destruction".
Spare Aryan: I didn't want to kill him or his man.
Help Iorveth: I helped him becouse of Zoltan and Triss.
Save Stennis: There is no proof he's guilty.
Save Triss: I came to Loc Muinne for her.
Spare Sheala, Dragon and Letho: I almost let Sheala die, but at last few seconds I decide to removed the diamond. She may became ally or help Geralt in TW3 (or he'll be forced to kill her anyway... well, at least we'll get some XP />/>/>/> ).
Saskia is probably one of the last living dragon. I can't just kill her. And maybe there is a small chance to remove a spell.
As for Letho... he gave me the answers, helped Yennefer, spared Geralt and fight at his side against the Wild Hunt. I don't see him as an enemy, so I let him go.

Full list of main characters I saved/spared/let go: Abigail, Thaler, Vincent, Adda, Letho, Sheala, Saskia, Stennis, Cynthia, Loredo, Berengar (he later died).
 
GHOSTMD

GHOSTMD

Senior user
#64
Nov 18, 2013
Greetz everybody

My first import path in TW3 ll be:

TW1
Save Abigail
Choose Triss
Spare Vincent
Sticked with Scoiatel
Save Thaler
peacefull solution on murky waters (dagon "conflict")
spared Berengar (but seems not to matter... even when he survives the fight with Azar)
save Adda
Refused to give Jacques to the Wild Hunt

TW2
spare Aryan
give Iorweth the sword
save the elven women
Choose Iorweth
spare Dennis
save Triss
Let Sile/ Sheala go
Spare dragon/Saskia
Kill Letho (a given word is a given word) only when i choosed Iorweth way, with roche i spared Letho

So far to my initial import for TW3

So long
 
D

daddy300

Mentor
#65
Dec 3, 2013
It's hard to choose between two saves, Roche and Iorweth. I dont think it will matter much since TW3 is coming to PS4 and X1 and they wont have option to import old saves.

But I would like to see Dethmold and Letho alive in TW3 as they were pretty crazy but I dont think it will be possible.

I still dream about Letho stand alone DLC.
 
O

otokage

Rookie
#66
Dec 6, 2013
I don’t think I understood the second part of the pool very good. But anyway my TW2 save is:

SPARE ARYAN
GIVE SWORD
CHOOSE IORVETH
SAVE MOTTLE
SPARE STENNIS
SPARE HENSELT
GO WITH PHILIPPA
SAVE SILE
DISENCHANT SASKIA
KILL LETHO (I planned to spare him, but then I realized I wanted him and Nilfgaard emperor dead)

I also helped Cynthia and trolls.
 
m4x1u

m4x1u

Senior user
#67
Dec 7, 2013
How do you guys get to make a decision regarding Henselt while on Iorveth path?

My first Enhanced Edition Dark Mode play went like this:

SPARED ARYAN
PUNCHED IORWETH
SIDED WITH IORWETH
SAVED MOTTLE
LYNCHED STENNIS
HELPED PHILIPPA/SPELLBREAKER
SAVED SILE
SASKIA'S CURSE LIFTED
LET LETHO GO


Made sweet love to Triss.
Spared trolls.
Spared Succubus.
Cynthia took artifact.
Slayed the operator.
Stayed neutral wherever possible.
Made full Kinslayer armor, had all best swords on me when finishing the game (vran, caerme, addan deith etc.)
 
C

Cs__sz__r

Rookie
#68
Dec 7, 2013
There is no choice for Henselt if you go with Iorveth.
 
O

otokage

Rookie
#69
Dec 7, 2013
Csszr said:
There is no choice for Henselt if you go with Iorveth.
Click to expand...
When you win the war at Vergen, the game let's you choose some things regarding Henselt, or maybe I'm confusing it with another playthrough. Also when u sneak in Henselt's campament to get his blood, it appeared to me that maybe you could kill him or something?
 
V

vivaxardas2015

Rookie
#70
Dec 7, 2013
Otokage said:
When you win the war at Vergen, the game let's you choose some things regarding Henselt, or maybe I'm confusing it with another playthrough. Also when u sneak in Henselt's campament to get his blood, it appeared to me that maybe you could kill him or something?
Click to expand...
No, on Iorveth path there is no choice about Henselt at all. Vergen always wins, Henselt always surrenders and takes Sile as his adviser. If Geralt comes for his blood, it is only an in-game cut-scene with no choice. Henselt gives his blood willingly to lift the curse.
 
O

otokage

Rookie
#71
Dec 7, 2013
vivaxardas said:
No, on Iorveth path there is no choice about Henselt at all. Vergen always wins, Henselt always surrenders and takes Sile as his adviser. If Geralt comes for his blood, it is only an in-game cut-scene with no choice. Henselt gives his blood willingly to lift the curse.
Click to expand...
I see, thank you :)
 
Elegast7

Elegast7

Senior user
#72
Dec 12, 2013
Just a quick question to the people who have read the books. What choices do you think the Geralt from the books would have made in both TW and TW2?
 
S

servetheunicorn

Rookie
#73
Dec 17, 2013
The choices I want to import are:

TW1

-Save the Lab
-Don't make deal with the squirrels
-Save Abigail
-Expose Raymond
-Help Order in the swamp
-Choose Shani
-Save Thaler
-Cure Vincent
-Help Order at the bank
-Spare Berengar
-Achieve a compromise in Murky Waters
-Side with the Order
-Spare Adda
-Kill the King of the Wild Hunt

TW2

-Spare Aryan
-Help Roche
-Choose Roche
-Spare Adam
-Spare Henselt
-Accuse Kimbolt & Maravel
-Save Anais
-Give Anais to Radovid
-Let Sile die
-Kill Dragon
-Spare Letho
 
Last edited: Jan 31, 2015
R

Rhygaar

Forum regular
#74
Dec 26, 2013
I haven't finished it yet but I'm replaying my first walkthrough to include the EE choices (Lilies & Vipers).

TW1

- Go with Triss (to the lab)
- Save Abigail
- Choose Triss
- Save Thaler
- Cure Vincent
- Achieve a compromise in Murky Waters
- Walk the Witcher Path (Stay Neutral)
- Save Adda
- Don't let the King of the Wild Hunt get Jacques' soul

TW2

- Spare Aryan
- Don't give Iorveth his sword back
- Choose Roche
- Spare Adam
- Spare Henselt
- Accuse both Kimbolt & Maravel
- Save Triss
- Spare Sile
- Spare Dragon
- Spare Letho

This is what I feel the Geralt from the book would have done :
- stay true to your friends (Triss, Roche),
- spare people when you can,
- avoid needlessly taking sides when you can walk the Witcher Path
- do not kill sentient beings (trolls, dragon)

These are the choices I will import in TW3. The other two saves I will later import to see the changes are :
- Geralt, protector of Foltest's legacy : in TW1 side with Siegfried (more than the Order itself) and choose Shani, in TW2 go with Roche, save Anaïs in Loc Muinne and convince Roche to entrust her to Natalis. I think a regency council made of the military leader - Natalis, the most prominent (noble) politician - Vizima Burgomaster Velerad and the Head of Temeria Intelligence Services - Thaler would be very fitting to handle the situation.
- Geralt, Nilfgaard's Nemesis : in TW1 stay neutral and choose Triss (same as above), in TW2 go with Iorveth and save Triss (also kill Adalbert and Cynthia in Secrets of Loc Muinne, and Letho as well in the epilogue). No servant of Emhyr escapes him.

Thanks Servethe Unicorn for the template !
 
Last edited: Feb 8, 2014
B

Belzebutinov

Senior user
#75
Feb 3, 2014
Oddly enough (am I the only one?), I'm actually more conflicted about my TW 1 choices than my TW 2 choices.

TW1

Save Abigail (surprisingly difficult choice)
Choose Triss
Save Vincent and Thaler
Hardest choice: go pure neutral or choose Siegfried (I've done both in my last playthroughs and still can't choose.... Pure neutral seems more canon, but Siegfried is really the kind of man "canon" Geralt would actually befriend - not to mention he goes quite astray if you don't choose him...)


TW2
Spare Aryan
Choose Roche
Spare Henselt
Kill Sile
Save Triss
Kill the Dragon
Spare Letho

My reasoning in TW2 is the following. Roche is the absolute obvious choice, if only for one reason: Geralt really, really hates being poked in the ribs with pitchforks. I wonder why. Anyways, as things stand, he is branded a regicide, which is pretty much the worst thing possible in terms of living a peaceful life. Roche is more or less the only person who can fix that. Forget patriotism: this is about survival, and ensuring a decent future. Running away with Iorveth - who is not just a Scoiatel, but who is actually actively involved in the murder - is tantamount to confessing the murder. Geralt doesn't care about Foltest being avenged, even though he found him somewhat more likeable than the other monarchs. He cares about being able to walk down a street without every other person trying to gut him. What's more, Roche, for all his defaults, is at least somewhat reliable. He has his goals, but you quickly get the feeling that he won't sell you out to accomplish them; the way he cares about his men makes it plain that if you're one of his, he will work you to the bone, but will never throw you under the bus. Iorveth, on the other hand, doesn't seem to inspire that kind of trust.

Henselt: I understand those who say Geralt wouldn't stop a man from exacting his revenge, but I somehow feel he'd make an exception here. For those who have read the books, Geralt is no stranger to politics and power plays, even though he doesn't like them much. Still, if only because he wants to someday live a peaceful life, and because he knows a Nilfgaardian yoke is not going to do well (Emhyr, despite sparing him in their last encounter, is not exactly a pushover), I do think that in his eyes, sparing one bastard to help protect thousands of people who don't deserve to die would be an acceptable compromise.

Last major choice (I'll get back to letho later, but he's a nobrainer to me): saving Triss. I've played a few other options, but saving Triss just feels like the right thing to do. Saving Anais, in my opinion, could only be justified if you see it - which I would understand - as Geralt somehow trying to make up for losing Ciri. Patriotism isn't his forte, so I can much more easily see him going after Triss, for whom he genuinely cares for and has good reason to worry for, rather than for a child who, regardless of the danger she is in, is nothing more than a pawn .This may sound a bit contradictory to my stance regarding Henselt, but I don't thing it's incompatible. Henselt is king NOW, and killing him would provoke utter turmoil. Anais is not so important; Foltest is dead already, and while Anais could become a stabilising factor, the North can do without her more easily than it can do without that bastard Henselt. Not to mention that freeing Triss allows to set up a stronger mage alliance, which might hopefully lead to a Sodden Hill miracle rather than letting Nilfgaard steemroll through (assuming, of course, you don't want Nilfgaard to rule - arguments could be made that Nilfgaard is a stronger, more stable and peaceful model than the northern kingdoms, but that's another debate entirely).


Last and somewhat least, Letho: Letho is not my enemy. I don't care that he works for Emhyr, he's a big boy. If he gets offered a job he doesn't want, he'll work around it. I don't know, I just trust him to be more of an asset than a liability. I'll happily fight by his side for a change.
 
  • RED Point
Reactions: Jobbert.907 and vivaxardas2015
G

goopit

Forum veteran
#76
Feb 4, 2014
Belzebutinov said:
Running away with Iorveth - who is not just a Scoiatel, but who is actually actively involved in the murder - is tantamount to confessing the murder.
Click to expand...
My Geralt didn't give a fuck about that he wanted to save Triss, that's why he went with the elves. Roche fucked up in the elven baths, if it wasn't for him you would've already captured Letho and now he wants to go on some mission to kill Loredo then go to Henselt. You could argue that Henselt might immediately kill Geralt on sight because he's a kingslayer. Ceadric says Letho took Triss to Vergen and that's exactly where Iorveth is going.
 
V

ViLarco.400

Rookie
#77
Feb 4, 2014
In the first game Geralt needed allies against Salamandra. It was an obvious choice, because the Order is a bunch of pro-human lunatics. Saved everyone along the way. Told King of the Wild Hunt to go plough himself.

In the second game it was an obvious choice again, Roche wanted to kill Loredo and then go who knows where, but Iorveth wanted to go straight to Vergen where Triss teleported herself and Letho. Met cool dwarfs like Yarpen, Sheldon, Cecil and Skalen, so it was a pleasure helping them against Henselt. In Loc Muinne saved Triss, because she was the only reason I chose Iorveth in the first place. Saved everyone along the way except Adalbert and Cynthia.
 
V

vivaxardas2015

Rookie
#78
Feb 4, 2014
Belzebutinov said:
Running away with Iorveth - who is not just a Scoiatel, but who is actually actively involved in the murder - is tantamount to confessing the murder.

Anais is not so important; Foltest is dead already, and while Anais could become a stabilising factor, the North can do without her more easily than it can do without that bastard Henselt. Not to mention that freeing Triss allows to set up a stronger mage alliance, which might hopefully lead to a Sodden Hill miracle rather than letting Nilfgaard steemroll through (assuming, of course, you don't want Nilfgaard to rule - arguments could be made that Nilfgaard is a stronger, more stable and peaceful model than the northern kingdoms, but that's another debate entirely).
Click to expand...
Yep, going with Iorveth who is as much Foltest's assassin as Letho, is completely counter-intuitive if Geralt's main purpose is to clear his name. Nobody would even believe that Geralt wasn't on it with them, given that he personally knows one assassin and allied with another. Even Triss' testimony shouldn't be enough because she is a defected member of the same organization that commissioned regicides.

Yes, this whole deal was about the mages, and I just couldn't let it happen that all good work with Thanedd went to dogs. You know, it is not even funny anymore - first war - Sodden Hill. Bad mages, let's have Thanedd. 2nd war - Brenna, and Northern victory, partially thanks to the Lodge. Bad sorceresses. Get rid of them ASAP! A new Council? Are you frigging kidding me? Let's have a nice little massacre, it sure looks more epic. Loc Muinne painted with blood was such a sight! CDPR provided me with a perfect ending in TW2. I hope in TW3 I'll see at last all the lands between Yaruga and Pontar becoming Nilfgaardian provinces. Being wholeheartedly for Nilfgaard, I also did not have any problems choosing.
 
  • RED Point
Reactions: Belzebutinov
G

goopit

Forum veteran
#79
Feb 4, 2014


Canon Playthrough Basically stayed neutral and saved any good people I could and was only lovers with Triss. I went with Iorveth because Triss was more important than clearing my name, also rescued Triss instead of Saskia. I killed Letho because the world doesn't need new witchers and children dying. Witchers are almost always heroes while Assassins are just tools, plus I owed Roche.



Death follows Geralt Playthrough everything fucking dies around this motherfucker! this Geralt also wants allies which is why he went with the Order. killed Abigail because she summoned the beast and Geralt was scared of dying by pitchfork. I killed Thaler thinking I'd improve my relations with Siegfried and the Order. I rescued Anais but I supported Nilfgaard and Maravel, basically everything canon Geralt wouldn't do this Geralt would do including giving Alvin to the Wild Hunt.
 
B

Belzebutinov

Senior user
#80
Feb 4, 2014
guipit said:
My Geralt didn't give a fuck about that he wanted to save Triss, that's why he went with the elves.
Click to expand...
My Geralt didn't get overly worried to be honest. Triss has proven time and again that she is more than capable of handling herself. The reason I put so much emphasis on Geralt wanting to clear his name (not to be confused with some silly patriotic "for Temeria!" nonsense) is because he has no chance of living this down. Foltest was not some random nobody, and Geralt is quite well-known in his own right. He really stands out: a white-haired witcher? There are few witchers around as it is, and none of them, barring Vesemir (to my knowledge at least), have a great shock of flowing white hair.

Most people don't like witchers to start with. But a kingslaying witcher allied with scoiatel terrorists? Bring the pitchforks and the torches ladies and gentlemen, it's time to gut some witchers - and my Geralt most definitely believes that once is enough. And that's not evening mentioning the assassins people like Henselt might send, out of both vengeance and fear.

And if he doesn't clear his name: where can he go? As I just said, anywhere in the North is unsafe. Heck, if Kaer Morhen isn't safe, nowhere in the North is. The northern, neutral monarchs won't have him, that's for sure. Dijkstra probably still limps thanks to him by the way, so Geralt had best stay faaaaar away from the North.

Nilfgaard then? Emhyr may have spared him last time, but as I see it, he did so more out of concern for Ciri, who saw Geralt and Yen as her surrogate parents, but I don't see him asylum and welcoming him with open arms either. Don't forget: Geralt is one of the only people who know Emhyr's deepest, darkest secrets. He is the very definition of a loose end, and Emhyr won't want that within a thousand miles if he can help it (and he most certainly help it).


Geralt has no choice but to clear his name if he wants to have a shot at a life without daily attempts on his life. His memory is coming back, he's starting to remember Yen & Ciri, he wants to find them. Angry mobs and assassins coming after him do not fit into that plan. So he bites the bullet, trusts Triss to at the very least hang on until he can intervene (which he does in Loc Muinne), and makes the only rational choice he can.



new&improved_vivaxardas said:
Yes, this whole deal was about the mages, and I just couldn't let it happen that all good work with Thanedd went to dogs. You know, it is not even funny anymore - first war - Sodden Hill. Bad mages, let's have Thanedd. 2nd war - Brenna, and Northern victory, partially thanks to the Lodge. Bad sorceresses. Get rid of them ASAP! A new Council? Are you frigging kidding me? Let's have a nice little massacre, it sure looks more epic. Loc Muinne painted with blood was such a sight! CDPR provided me with a perfect ending in TW2. I hope in TW3 I'll see at last all the lands between Yaruga and Pontar becoming Nilfgaardian provinces. Being wholeheartedly for Nilfgaard, I also did not have any problems choosing.
Click to expand...
I couldn't agree more. Now personally, my Geralt doesn't much care either way, but maybe he prefers not living under Emhyr's boot, for obvious reasons (as stated above). Also, it's no mystery that Geralt is not on friendly terms with most sorceresses. Assire learnt that the hard way when she realized that pretty much everything he confessed in bed was a flat-out lie. He very much boned her in every sense of the word on that one. Triss and Yen are pretty much the only sorceresses he can put up with. But if sorceresses are bad as it is, scheming sorceresses are even worse. Also, these scheming sorceresses are more than likely going to be problematic vis-à-vis Ciri. There's no sense in letting that Lodge keep on going. Dismantling it in public is therefore Geralt's best move.


This leads me to also point out two things I forgot in my initial post.

First off, Sile dies. I used to spare her, mainly because I do think that, despite his rough approach in general, Geralt is somethign of a gentleman in his own way, and watching a woman writhe in pain and die isn't his style. But then, it hit me that this one was, not one minute ago, actively trying to have me eaten by a bloody dragon. Lady, not cool. Not only is that bint trying to kill me, but even as she fails to do so, she jumps into a portal promising to kill me as soon as she can. If that portal backfires and tears her to shreds, don't expect me to lift my little finger. Karma is one hell of a bitch, ain't it?

Second: the dragon dies. I understand that Geralt is extremely adverse to killing such an intelligent and majestic beast. He'd much rather enjoy a beer, a nice dinner and a tub with her than stab her in the throat. However, two things need to be pointed out:
1) The dragon has a fucking tree trunk sticking through its chest. I know it takes a lot to kill a dragon, but just walking away is stone-cold cruel. That thing is not likely going to walk away alive, or at the very least is going to be crippled and maimed for the rest of its life. Finishing it off is the humane thing to do.
2) The bloody thing is mind-controlled. Geralt doesn't kill sentient beings unless it can't be helped. This dragon isn't thinking for itself, and is unquestionably a threat to other people. Either you can break the mind-control spell, either you put an end to the threat in another way... the only one left. Stabby stabby.
 
  • RED Point
Reactions: vivaxardas2015
Prev
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • 6
  • 7
Next
First Prev 4 of 7

Go to page

Next Last
Share:
Facebook Twitter Reddit Pinterest Tumblr WhatsApp Email Link
  • English
    English Polski (Polish) Deutsch (German) Русский (Russian) Français (French) Português brasileiro (Brazilian Portuguese) Italiano (Italian) 日本語 (Japanese) Español (Spanish)

STAY CONNECTED

Facebook Twitter YouTube
CDProjekt RED Mature 17+
  • Contact administration
  • User agreement
  • Privacy policy
  • Cookie policy
  • Press Center
© 2018 CD PROJEKT S.A. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED

The Witcher® is a trademark of CD PROJEKT S. A. The Witcher game © CD PROJEKT S. A. All rights reserved. The Witcher game is based on the prose of Andrzej Sapkowski. All other copyrights and trademarks are the property of their respective owners.

Forum software by XenForo® © 2010-2020 XenForo Ltd.