It seems fair to say that O'Dimm first of all is not anything like god nor the devil or evil as the professor describes.
There might be a bit of a mistake in trying to take O'Dimm's actions too literally, which I might do, and also I'm sure there are some inconsistencies in what he does in the game, making so it's not possible to assume everything is perfectly consistent.
But so I finished O'stone recently and rewatched his meeting at white orchard with Geralt.
I think it's fair to say that he is not omniscient, just as he claims himself. And I think not just for story reasons. He asks Geralt why exactly he wants to find Yennefer, and clearly doesn't know. I gather that he goes around in many places at once, maybe becoming an obtainer or merchant of information.
Olgierd tried to summon Gaunter. I think that could indicate that O'Dimm has some kind of definite identity and should have pretty hard bounds. Also, an issue to raise. O'Dimm shows up whenever and wherever he wants to but doesn't when Olgeird wants to bring him up? Furthermore Olgierd seems to later hate O'Dimm and apparently has once set his dogs on O'Dimm. For a guy who can kill someone in an instant on a whim (in the tavern) and also apparently threaten Geralt the same when they were on the 'moon' this is very weird.
Also I find it very curious why O'Dimm has a hatred for 'unscrupulous' individuals. He puts a fly in someone's soup. He makes Vlodimir suffer as a spirit. Anyone understand the reason why he insists that Olgierd is a horrible man? Seems like a part of his trick to convince Geralt, right?
I actually would personally venture that in the ending O'Dimm was banished in some way, similar to how you banish the Hym, or other monsters and maybe we could do better than this (if we really tried and wanted).
O'Dimm has some tools at his disposal but not everything and anything. I think that if O'Dimm were taken very literally, Geralt can ask to become the emperor of Nilfgaard. I would speculate that this is either not something O'Dimm can actually do or wants to do.
The most interesting moment to me was interactions with the professor. I think this says a lot about O'Dimm but am not sure what to make of it. I wonder if the professor learned of his name?
Furthermore what's very interesting is how O'Dimm denies Geralt what he actually considers a wish when Geralt asks for his name. I think that it indicates O'Dimm makes pacts because and when he believes they benefit him. Having Geralt killed by learning his name would not help him in this situation. Also could just be a story thing, would be very weird for Geralt to never want to do the natural thing and ask for O'Dimm's name.
Also I want to add that I'm greatly frustrated by how little appreciation Olgierd shows for me risking my very soul to save him for from what he would see, no reason whatsoever. Absolutely disproportional. I got a decent sword that'll fall behind in 5 levels.
There might be a bit of a mistake in trying to take O'Dimm's actions too literally, which I might do, and also I'm sure there are some inconsistencies in what he does in the game, making so it's not possible to assume everything is perfectly consistent.
But so I finished O'stone recently and rewatched his meeting at white orchard with Geralt.
I think it's fair to say that he is not omniscient, just as he claims himself. And I think not just for story reasons. He asks Geralt why exactly he wants to find Yennefer, and clearly doesn't know. I gather that he goes around in many places at once, maybe becoming an obtainer or merchant of information.
Olgierd tried to summon Gaunter. I think that could indicate that O'Dimm has some kind of definite identity and should have pretty hard bounds. Also, an issue to raise. O'Dimm shows up whenever and wherever he wants to but doesn't when Olgeird wants to bring him up? Furthermore Olgierd seems to later hate O'Dimm and apparently has once set his dogs on O'Dimm. For a guy who can kill someone in an instant on a whim (in the tavern) and also apparently threaten Geralt the same when they were on the 'moon' this is very weird.
Also I find it very curious why O'Dimm has a hatred for 'unscrupulous' individuals. He puts a fly in someone's soup. He makes Vlodimir suffer as a spirit. Anyone understand the reason why he insists that Olgierd is a horrible man? Seems like a part of his trick to convince Geralt, right?
I actually would personally venture that in the ending O'Dimm was banished in some way, similar to how you banish the Hym, or other monsters and maybe we could do better than this (if we really tried and wanted).
O'Dimm has some tools at his disposal but not everything and anything. I think that if O'Dimm were taken very literally, Geralt can ask to become the emperor of Nilfgaard. I would speculate that this is either not something O'Dimm can actually do or wants to do.
The most interesting moment to me was interactions with the professor. I think this says a lot about O'Dimm but am not sure what to make of it. I wonder if the professor learned of his name?
Furthermore what's very interesting is how O'Dimm denies Geralt what he actually considers a wish when Geralt asks for his name. I think that it indicates O'Dimm makes pacts because and when he believes they benefit him. Having Geralt killed by learning his name would not help him in this situation. Also could just be a story thing, would be very weird for Geralt to never want to do the natural thing and ask for O'Dimm's name.
Also I want to add that I'm greatly frustrated by how little appreciation Olgierd shows for me risking my very soul to save him for from what he would see, no reason whatsoever. Absolutely disproportional. I got a decent sword that'll fall behind in 5 levels.
Last edited: