@TheMorbidAtheist I really don't understand the point you're trying to make. Your friend can start saving up money and decide later, when the gameplay trailers start coming in, if he wants to continue saving cash. The money will still be in his possession, he's allowed to spend them on something else, they won't disappear.
As for Watch Dogs winning over The Witcher 3 on gamespot, TW3 won the IGN awards, which is an even bigger mainstream website, so I don't see how that's a valid argument. Are you suggesting that TW3 should be winning each and every award, because that's impossible, I'm afraid. What CDPR have achieved in terms of recognition - numerous nominations and awards for most anticipated game, decided both by fans and critics - given their limited monetary resources, is nothing short of remarkable.
As a side note, we actually know a lot more about the combat and how it's going to work than what you told your friend.