It wouldn't have been. If there was no character creator or clothing. I don't care about being stuck in first person, in Subnautica. Those two games do the same thing CP does. The only time you can see Ryley or Robin. Is with a robot penguin or a scanning camera. And when they do cut scenes. They take control of the player. So you don't have to manually move your face around. Proper cut scenes. They're dynamic. Not V sitting in a chair.I'm frankly amazed it's a point of contention.
FP is fine. But this is what they did wrong. FP, with real cut scenes. FP, with 3rd person mode for everything else that doesn't involve sitting down or sex. They just did FP and nothing else.