The story before Keanu Reeves (theory)

+
To be honest i thought we are gonna have a lot of choices and well we are gonna have systems in place to be made a legend in night city and well, this story is like 1st expansion for me... i dont know.. Imagine playing the whole game and having jackie and t- bug around and comes the first expansion and Dex returns in night city after 2 years - like he did in the game but now he is planning the biggest heist ever... And we get to know Evelyn here... and you know the rest.. And i truly believe that this was an expansion.. Because even if you are 1 street cred or 50 .. no one knows you... you dont matter.. if its not in some story related crap...

I think that was never going to happen because they would literally have to write the game three or four times and be larger in size -- and they didn't have time to finish what they had.

Mind you, I wish we could save Evelyn and Jackie.
 
SPOILERS, do not read if you haven’t played through all the endings
TL;DR
What do you think? Was Johnny Silverhand central to the story from the beginning of development?
I may not have played through all the endings yet but I dont really care. I like the path that I've taken with V and I have difficulty (right now) to change that perspective. And its all mostly because of the sad ending where life doesn't really mean life.
Personally wether or not johnny silverhand had such large part in it, probably not. As from Keanu's involvement perhaps yes, big name for the frame and all that.
Personally, I would just like to have much more time with my own V after the ending(s) of this game. I want my V to live, so let me have her live. I do think the silverhand thig kinda threw a whack at that perspective.
 
Well considering Johnny Silverhand is an integral part of the Cyberpunk lore,I honestly can't believe that they would change an entire game just for Keanu. I mean, the whole V getting offed and Johnny's engram taking over in order to save V was very cliché but it worked very well as all Johnny Silverhand was, is a voice in in your head and some of his commentary actually influenced some of my choices. The event where you play as Johnny is an actually story written in Cyberpunk Red(The pen and Paper game for those who don't know) and ties Cyberpunk 2077 and Red together.
 
They should have made the main quest of the game a quest to become a famous merc and revenge against the "enemy" that causes problems for the protagonist (exile from the Nomads, return from Atlanta, or get fired from Arasaka).

Johnny Silverhand's quest was more appropriate for a DLC.
 
They should have made the main quest of the game a quest to become a famous merc and revenge against the "enemy" that causes problems for the protagonist (exile from the Nomads, return from Atlanta, or get fired from Arasaka).

Johnny Silverhand's quest was more appropriate for a DLC.
Thank you! People keep excusing Johnny's dominance in this game because he was a big part of the PnP game. Was he the ONLY part of the PnP? This first game needed to establish V first and foremost, as this is the entry episode in a new medium and establish lore where you learn about Johnny through shards or something. THEN you bring Johnny in through DLC or sequel.
 
They should have made the main quest of the game a quest to become a famous merc and revenge against the "enemy" that causes problems for the protagonist (exile from the Nomads, return from Atlanta, or get fired from Arasaka).

Johnny Silverhand's quest was more appropriate for a DLC.

Getting fired from Arasaka is the best thing to ever happen to my merc. :)

But I think that we could have done more of the first Act of the Game before the Heist. I liked all the cast there.

Thank you! People keep excusing Johnny's dominance in this game because he was a big part of the PnP game. Was he the ONLY part of the PnP? This first game needed to establish V first and foremost, as this is the entry episode in a new medium and establish lore where you learn about Johnny through shards or something. THEN you bring Johnny in through DLC or sequel.

Speaking as a Cyberpunk 2020 player, there's kind of an amazing homage in the fact there's a board game for 2020 where you play as Jonny Silverhand, Rogue, Santiago, and Thomas the Media in an assault on Arasaka Tower where you have to try to rescue Alt Cunningham. It was kind of amazing to have that incorporated whole-cloth into the video game. It would be like playing a Forgotten Realms video game and then midway through you play "The Keep on the Borderlands."

Mike Pondsmith also said in the initial pitch it was about Alt Cunningham and Johnny's relationship. I think the big difference is that they set Johnny dying much earlier because they realized a guy who NUKED A CITY wasn't going to have a happy life as a celebrity for 50 years among the people he murdered the families of (however unintentionally). So Kerry became the aged old rocker.

Edit:

Ah, the game is "Never Fade Away": https://cyberpunk.fandom.com/wiki/Never_Fade_Away_(Adventure)
 
Speaking as a Cyberpunk 2020 player, there's kind of an amazing homage in the fact there's a board game for 2020 where you play as Jonny Silverhand, Rogue, Santiago, and Thomas the Media in an assault on Arasaka Tower where you have to try to rescue Alt Cunningham. It was kind of amazing to have that incorporated whole-cloth into the video game. It would be like playing a Forgotten Realms video game and then midway through you play "The Keep on the Borderlands."

Mike Pondsmith also said in the initial pitch it was about Alt Cunningham and Johnny's relationship. I think the big difference is that they set Johnny dying much earlier because they realized a guy who NUKED A CITY wasn't going to have a happy life as a celebrity for 50 years among the people he murdered the families of (however unintentionally). So Kerry became the aged old rocker.

Edit:

Ah, the game is "Never Fade Away": https://cyberpunk.fandom.com/wiki/Never_Fade_Away_(Adventure)
I like it and I'm not opposed to playing as PnP icons, but damn, let me get my feet wet in Night City first, before we get into the heavy lore.
 
I like it and I'm not opposed to playing as PnP icons, but damn, let me get my feet wet in Night City first, before we get into the heavy lore.

I think that was why they locked down Watson. They wanted you to enjoy 10-15 hours or so of content and sidequests before starting the main game.

A lot of fans either rushed through this or actively did not want to engage with the story of their character dying.
 
Y'know. with some heintsight, what I would've changed about the game would be the setup the act-count and therefore the games duration.
Act 1 through 3 should allow us to establish our V, have our fun with our V's and already start the ropect of building up some friends and even relationships while just roaming the world, working to make our name.
People like Panam, Judy, Claire, Evelyn, River and who else could serve as perfect potential relationships that could develop well before our "we're going to die" questline.
In my view, I would've like to intiiate in several missions with my 'significant other' (happens to have been Judy for me). The diving part was cool, but after that there was nothing, not even so much as a new speechcheck. And that I would've liked more off, have her and the other react to new stuff that you did after each 'main mission' or potential sidequest where you went on dates and stuff, give the relationship some time to blossom and found itself to our V.

And when those stones are in place and you have the foundation laid then the heist can come knocking around where we re all of a sudden burdened with the life expectancy of doomsday where we must race against the clock and odds to find a way to get the relic out of our heads. our established friends and relations can be pillars of support during this time via both speechchecks where they check in on you are (or you call them).
Maybe even allow dates at that point to provide some levity amidst the tense situations. When we fall apart our friends and relations may also fall apart, or just remains strong.
In short, All that happens from the heist as far as the main story goes, should've been an act 4 and 5.
Post automatically merged:

I think that was why they locked down Watson. They wanted you to enjoy 10-15 hours or so of content and sidequests before starting the main game.

A lot of fans either rushed through this or actively did not want to engage with the story of their character dying.
Well, I didn't know what was gonna happen so I didn't rush through it, but with a few jobs from 1 fixer and osome world events you weren't gonna spend very long before doing the heist anyway. 10 hours sounds already like quite alot before you'd do the heist and end up with relic-decease.
For me, as described it all could've been much more stretched and interweaved before that point, which could've been a soft version of point of no return in my eyes.
 
Well, I didn't know what was gonna happen so I didn't rush through it, but with a few jobs from 1 fixer and osome world events you weren't gonna spend very long before doing the heist anyway. 10 hours sounds already like quite alot before you'd do the heist and end up with relic-decease.
For me, as described it all could've been much more stretched and interweaved before that point, which could've been a soft version of point of no return in my eyes.

Well you have:

* The Introduction Life Path
* You have the Scavenger mission/Optional T-Bug training braindance
* You have meeting Misty and Viktor
* You meet with Dex
* You have the Maelstrom mission/possibly with Stout
* You have the Evelyn/Judy introduction/braindance
* You go on the Heist itself

You're right, this is like more 4-5 hours by itself.

I also did a bunch of sidequests inbetween.

It's a fairly lengthy act. The problem is I'd argue that Jackie/Evelyn/Dex are such GOOD characters that we COULD play an entire game with them and it would be awesome. Arguably, they're the best characters in the game.
 
Last edited:
The idea for Cyberpunk came in 2012. Ideas. Production for the game didn't start until 2016 so a lot can easily change in ideas over 4 years.

Oh, of course. I get that. I'm just curious about what their original idea for the story was--or if they even had one at that time. I love hearing stories about how things like Star Wars and whatnot were imagined very differently at the start. Even the conceptualization of unrealized projects such as Jodorowsky's Dune are interesting. Obviously, what could have been doesn't change anything in the present--but it's fascinating to read about nonetheless.
 
Oh, of course. I get that. I'm just curious about what their original idea for the story was--or if they even had one at that time. I love hearing stories about how things like Star Wars and whatnot were imagined very differently at the start. Even the conceptualization of unrealized projects such as Jodorowsky's Dune are interesting. Obviously, what could have been doesn't change anything in the present--but it's fascinating to read about nonetheless.
I get that. It's really hard to depict what they had going for them as that first scene with the cops unloading on that cybered up female in the streets didn't show anything. At least for me, all I saw was cops taking down a cybperpsycho.
 
Well you have:

* The Introduction Life Path
* You have the Scavenger mission/Optional T-Bug training braindance
* You have meeting Misty and Viktor
* You meet with Dex
* You have the Maelstrom mission/possibly with Stout
* You have the Evelyn/Judy introduction/braindance
* You go on the Heist itself

You're right, this is like more 4-5 hours by itself.

I also did a bunch of sidequests inbetween.

It's a fairly lengthy act. The problem is I'd argue that Jackie/Evelyn/Dex are such GOOD characters that we COULD play an entire game with them and it would be awesome. Arguably, they're the best characters in the game.
I'm also now just going off of the game we got, which btw, I like. Had much fun.
Act 1 was ok, I also have no issues with that, my biggest issue now, after some retrospective searching of my own is that my issue is that acts 2 and 3 should've been pushed back and give us some open world splender with the charcters in that 'gap'
because you're right, when we recover from Viktor's chair after he examined V for the relic, Dex was pretty much dead, Evelyn was gone (and basically dead already), Judy got put on hold to engage with, other than kicking off finding Evelyn, T-bug... I never realised she got offed until someone said it way later. I did run into meredith Stout once for that Maelstrom mission. Never seen or heard from again after.
Act 2 and onwards (for me) introduced basically:
-Johnny/Rogue (whereby Rogue was useless as a character because there was near zero interaction.)
-Panam and the Alvecaldos
-Takamura.
-Delamain, which I though was a funny one.
ooh, and 3,75 of races with Claire, which I also came out off rather dissapointed because her arc was up and that was that. You could speak to her in Afterlife, but I had already done the speechchecks about Jackie so there wasn't anything new there.
And if you consider the weight that Act 2 threw on you... it was rather overshadowing of the rest.
I also noticed many side jobs just didn't trigger until... fuck knows. I got delamain virus job only after I had already finished the game, becasue I got sent back to the exact moment where I would've walked through the doors visiting the Embers, and then wait like half an hour.
 
I get that. It's really hard to depict what they had going for them as that first scene with the cops unloading on that cybered up female in the streets didn't show anything. At least for me, all I saw was cops taking down a cybperpsycho.

True, I mean it was seven years ago so I can't remember what exactly I was thinking at the time. I was a pretty different person then, too. I remember being excited and thinking it was really cool at the time but I forgot about it pretty quickly. A lot changed for me since then; by the time they started showing more in 2017/2018, I wasn't sure I was even interested in that style of sci-fi anymore.

So I wasn't even that hyped but I was still curious. It was just weird to suddenly think about something I hadn't thought of for seven years, y'know? Felt like I had to at least try it. Not gonna go into detail about it here, but I definitely have mixed feelings about the game overall. Though I'd say I lean a bit more to the positive side than most people--at least in regards to the story.
 
Personally I think we will never get an official indepth answer on that topic, for it would just add fuel to the fire.

Nice to read the speculations, though!
 
Also worth noting that in voice recording, it is normal to cast late in production so the story, dialogue and overall structure of the game is less likely to change or get re-ordered. This way you can provide a script to a voice actor that is coherent, won't get rewritten a bunch of times and can be recorded in a single session (if possible), or in multiple sessions that are close together. This avoids scheduling conflicts, limits studio time and the voice actors are better able to deliver lines without jarring differences in cadence and tone so it makes the delivery more consistent too, which is really important for multiple choice dialogue.

Scheduling is a big deal. Just look at Cherami Leigh's 2020 filmography. I count 21 different productions in a single year. She is a highly sought after actress with a wall to wall work schedule. You have to first get her on board with the project and then book studio time way in advance. Then you have to fly her out to Poland for a week to get her lines recorded.

If you keep re-writing the script and adding bits onto it, you have to somehow fit it around all of her extant professional commitments to other studios, and for what? To redo 20 lines in a dialogue sequence between V and Johnny? Ok, now you have to go get Keanu Reeves and Gavin Drea back in the studio and somehow fit that time around their professional commitments too. Do this for every voice actor in the game where you need a re-write. You see how this can become a problem if the writing process is not tightly controlled?

There are a handful of lines in the game that I suspect were re-recorded at a much later date compared to the rest of the dialogue sequence because there is a big tonal difference from one line to another. But overall I found this to be pretty rare playing as Miss V.

If the voice talent was cast too early and the story changed significantly after the initial recording sessions, then these sorts of tonal shifts in delivery would be all over the game, and they simply aren't.
 
Last edited:
Personally I think we will never get an official indepth answer on that topic, for it would just add fuel to the fire.

Nice to read the speculations, though!
probably for the best, its not like it'll change anything now.
And who knows, if CDPR comes through with awesome added contend to make this game into what it could've been (a la no man sky) maybe in a years time from now, nobody will even care.
 
True, I mean it was seven years ago so I can't remember what exactly I was thinking at the time. I was a pretty different person then, too. I remember being excited and thinking it was really cool at the time but I forgot about it pretty quickly. A lot changed for me since then; by the time they started showing more in 2017/2018, I wasn't sure I was even interested in that style of sci-fi anymore.

So I wasn't even that hyped but I was still curious. It was just weird to suddenly think about something I hadn't thought of for seven years, y'know? Felt like I had to at least try it. Not gonna go into detail about it here, but I definitely have mixed feelings about the game overall. Though I'd say I lean a bit more to the positive side than most people--at least in regards to the story.
To be fair, not all of us saw Cyberpunk as a new flavor video game. I've been playing the pen and paper game since the early 90's and I'm a huge fan so to hear about Night City being made and brought to life in a video game, I knew I was going to be purchasing no matter what. Story wise and gameplay wise, I think it's a masterpiece. When I compare it to the pen and paper game, it's a giant turd
 
Top Bottom