Man, I knew there had to be one positive thread amid this sea of nitpicking and complaining.
I'm about 4-5 hours in, and I'm really, really sorry to report that for the most part the game is awesome. My only complaint is that the controls still feel too floaty - somehow moreso than in TW2. Everything else is great. The game runs well, looks gorgeous, and the writing is up to CDPR's usual standards. In fact, since I haven't progressed much in the main story yet, what strikes me the most at the moment is how every single sidequest seems to have nearly the production values of a full-blown story quest. Fully developed dialogue, cutscenes, interesting decisions, the works.
And also, good lord, the character faces. Are these all modeled after real people? Because they certainly seem that way. I guess eventually I'll notice faces repeating themselves like in the previous games and that'll wear off, but at the moment, I'm pretty blown away by how good even totally minor, throwaway characters look.
So yeah. No doubt this thread will be back on page 3 again by noon today, but maybe a few other people who aren't faceless profiles with two posts only created to scream "preorder cancelled" and "worst game ever" would like to chime in.