My thoughts and wish list:
1 - Area Loot -Is all good no troubles. Rethinkg your control layout
2 - Auto Pickup of Herbs - Ummm NO .. HELL no ... first ... you are not a goddamn PACKMAN ... if you want herbs dedicate 10 15 min of your time and search for them
3 - Durability / Repair System - IT could be reduced yes... they are breaking indeed very fast. I went with the quest with the witch 100% silver sword at then end itwas at 27% and I didn't had any repari kits in me. This was very frustratiing.
4 - Fall Damage - Tap space to make a roll barrel and he won't loose his vitality. A bit reduce of the fall damage would be nice.
5 - Inventory Weight Issues - They are perfect.
6 Dismantle Tab Issues - what is this?
7 - Equipment Level Restrictions - IS is suppose to e a RPG game right ???
8 - Camera Zoom - Because of the streaming technology and how the things are rendered specifically according to the camera so this is not an option at all. And will never be.
9 - Regenerating Potions & Bombs - They are perfectly applicable and works for me. However I would like to have my 4 pockets and place whatever I want in them like 4 bombs or 4 potions.
11 - Sprinting - Make the coold down little bit longer, not insta regenerate
12 - Looting on horse - OH cmooon this would be ridiculous
13 - Stealing - I approve.
14 - Quest Tracking - There is nothing wrong about the quest tracking and marking it is perfect, if i want this quest mark it ... if I want that quest mark it .. I don't want having multiple markers on the minimap.
15 - Hotkeys - Approve a secondary button for key binding would be nice.
16 - Swapping to crossbow or swapping swords - Umm WHAT ?? I am managing just fine wiht the crossbow
17 - Monster EXP is non existent.- WROOONG it is ... just see your skill number then kill some monsters and see that the number is increased.
18 - No Buy Back System - This is is by far IN EVERY RPG game .. ??
19. There are multiple displacements of rocks and stalactites in caves and are hovering in the air. Also saw one bush hovering like that.
20. Remove the auto holstering weapon and autodraw IF I draw my weapon I DONT want to get eventually get holstered.
21. Improve the lock on system after LOCK out from a target my sword go in his glove and holster
22. Looting is perfectly fine with MOUSE AND KB
23. KB + mouse is the superior control for me - I have mad cats RAT mouse 5 model. And the dodge and heavy attacks are on the thumbs button, crossbow with scroll button, right mouse block, left mouse fast attack, Q for signs, and I have set three modes for my DPI : low for horse riding, medium for walking and running slow and spring, fastest for combat. Once I got used with the battle game mechanics and start to remember the time frames of the animations of the enemy and GERALT itself the game becomes waaaaaaaaay nicer I don't know why so many people are complaining I play this game at hardest. I have learned how to kill enemies while on horse with one blowstrike .. PRACTICE TIMING people ... battles are smoothly and realistic as HELL ...DODGE can be used towards enemies and strike them instead trying to run with SHIFT towards them or walk is too slow. Combine block, dodge and roll and all comes ot its place. OH and SIGN.
24. THe crafting system - Could be better but for now I don't pay much attention to it.
25. For me XBONE pad is just horrible control schematic .. M + KB for the true gamers.
26. Looting is just fine point camera towards the box or crate and hit E
27. Still waiting for the ground blood splatter, sometimes is there sometimes is not. Make them disappear when you move from the area like 20 metres away and if you come back not to be there, rather than seeing how they dissapear in thin air.
28. LOVE THE WEATHER ... i love how when high in sky a cloud passing through and it feels like in real world the area get's shaded.
29. I want the white Skills to be passive like +500 vitality and the SIGN for dialogues to be passive as well. Once I ran to a side quest where it was out of the slots and I had to bribe the peasant with 50 to get the information. And my last save was 20 min ago.
30. Sorting in the inventory menu would be great
31. Just to go out from a dialogue would be great I had to SKIP 10 min dialogues SMASHING the SPACE button of my KB just to load a previous savE\
32. My Left side of the HUD is constantly auto-hiding ... Why we have the options for the HUD when it acts on its own. I want to see my stamina and vitality all the time.
33. Make my sword not go in holster .. if I draw my sword I want to be drawn until I want it to put back it on my back. And when I lock a target and then UNLOCK it the sword goes off and by the time I draw it I'm dead meat.
34. FOV or zoom out cameras is just not possible duo to how the streaming engine is working.
35. INventory menu don't benefit from 1080p resolution and I have to scroll down the grid box while there is so much space below to be resized.
36. Get rid of that pop up that tells me I've switched from keyboard to controller, what makes you think I need to be told what device I'm using? - THis is really annoying all the time.
37. NPCs should at least comment when you're ransacking their house. -Agree
38. Merchants need to be fixed, the difference between the selling and buying values is ridiculous. - AGREE
39 More hotkeys, - AGREE
40. Weapon Oils and Quen buff indicators ! I need to know when those run out <.< I would like to see when QUeen is going out.
41. Herbs need indeed glossary, on which conditions they grow, in shades, on sun, in swamps in mountains on fields ETC would be awesome. Now there is no clue when you need a herb and how you can find one.
42. Make Books if we read them or not. Several times I had to go all over the notes and books to find the right info.
43. I WOULD LOVE TIME LASPE MEDITATION !
ALL IN ALL GAME OF THE DECADE ... can't wait for the improvements to come.