Yes probably one SK cards appears to add signifcantly more value than their already existing counterparts. The other one I consider to be less powerful.
Bear witcher mentor can easily be compared to
Giant Boar
- If played after having only 3 cards in hand its exactly the same as Giant Boar (7 provisions) on Melee.
- So you basically save 2 provisions for the adrenaline downside and the missing Range opportunity.
- Would prefer his strength to be 3
For Gerd the comparision with Hemdall is more difficult:
- Both have a strength of 8 but Gerd is 5 provisions cheaper
- Hemdall is often played as a finisher (or 2nd finisher if there is Wild Boar of the Sea).
- if you want to avoid adrenaline than you need at least 5 cards in your hand which basically equals the provision difference. But your opponent gets +1 (damaged siren)
- If you face adrenaline it´s just a 9 for 7.