I agree, but the argument I am making is this thread has a toxic feel about it, not a suggested improvement feel. There is a toxic air about this game that is unwarranted. CDR can fix a lot of the things in this game with criticism, I agree, but the level of toxicity surrounding the criticism is going to have the reverse effect possibly. Why would they want to continue providing free content, being friends of the consumers, when the moment they stumble (and that stumble is highly debatable) there is an out pour of moaning and whining that will not cease, and when people defend the game they are bashed as fanboys? CDPR releases extra content for free in an age when NO extra content is free, and what has that netted them? Absolutely no loyalty.
So I guess I'm trying to say posts that start with "What are you disappointed with" come off as highly negative and shitty as opposed to "suggested improvements." I think CDPR has earned a bit of that from the fans. But I see I'm in the minority there.
Also, if they fixed nothing, I would still rank this my favorite game because: The story is amazing and gripping--even the sidequests are well written and moving. But things like the Crones quest are so well done, I literally couldn't make a decision at times, and the outcome still bugs me. The music is amazing, I absolutely love it, the best of the three games, my favorite soundtrack yet, and Geralt is perfectly captured from the books but also you are allowed to take him in a narrative progression that he always seemed to be moving towards in the novels and short stories. I wouldn't change my view if CDPR kept the game as is. I have had not a single crash (and I have an AMD video card!), only one freeze in 40 hours, and I am playing on ultra and it is beautiful. I don't know what else I could ask for. More Triss I guess, but I imagine that might come.
Edit: I will say I do appreciate your civility in response too. Thanks!
---------- Updated at 12:06 PM ----------
Well I have these gems too: "This game is great, it is a great build on the previous two entries in the series. Where Witcher 2 was exponentially better than the first, so too is this game." So I like that the games get better with every iteration as a logical reason. And then lorewise: "Think of the Qunari for example. One game they're like big humans, the next they're horned demons. At least Zoltan stayed aesthetically similar throughout because there was a respect for the fans from the company." They have consistent lore, and I guess this requires reading between the lines because later I write: "I'm going to go read my Witcher books" as a way of taking a break from the game, meaning I must love the story, characters, and lore. But I'll spell it out. Obviously more logical reasons would be the game has just consumed my imagination: "I haven't seen the sunshine, and when I went to the park the other day, forcing myself to get out of here for some exercise, I went to the park map which is on a giant board and for a second thought I was searching for Witcher notices."
Anyway, there are my examples. I could repeat the same stock stuff everyone else does for you if you want.