If CDPR get the removal balance right in coming updates I think it'll change a lot of minds over HC.
What is wrong with removal? I personally find it good as it is. What I find troublesome is manipulation with opponents deck. In MtG, discard and mill are the most oppressive tactics and some Nilfgard cards are quite reminding such tactic. At example
Isbel of Hagge, Traheaern Var Udyffir, Cantarella. If some players mind removal, those cards are one step above removal. At example, why Cantarella can not play copy of my card instead of card itself?
What I like in Gwent?
I like to open kegs and let me surprise with cards in them. I do not know all cards from homecoming and so many cards I see for the first time when opponent plays them or when I open them from keg. Then I like to make my decks with new cards or if I already have deck, where that new card would fit, I like improving my decks. Thinking what card would fit there and if there are more, sometimes it is hard to chose which card should be there and which card has to be returned back to collection. Yes, it is new player experience, which will not last for long time, because eventually, I will learn all cards in set and I will see the most used ones in opponents deck, but so far, Gwent is very entertaining exploration for me, so I try to enjoy it, while it lasts.