So, I just wasted a few minutes going through the thread, and perhaps not surprisingly a lot of the same games turn up over and over again. I didn't count very carefully and I forgot to add up some games, but here's what I got. These are the ones with 10 or more people endorsing them. Lots of RPGs, obviously. A couple shooters, a couple strategy games. Strategy games are my top genre, but on the forum for an RPG game I don't think you'd expect anything else, really. Results not guaranteed to be remotely accurate:The Witcher: clear winner so far, making 35 lists. I'm not so shocked, given that this is, you know, the Witcher forum.Elder Scrolls - I was too lazy to differentiate between them, but lots of people put Morrowind and Oblivion, so at least 2/3 of this is either of those. Combined TES (including a couple Daggerfall and I think a Battlespire): 33Baldur's Gate - all of 'em combined, but mostly people said 2: 17. I remember being at a friends house for his birthday, and he got Baldur's Gate 2. We fired it up and played it for pretty much the whole weekend straight. Taking shifts, we beat it for the first time in only a few days. It was hardcore.Gothic series: 15. I never played much of these, I don't know much about them. Gothic 3 was a buggy POS, for the few minutes I tried it. Most people said 1 and 2, though, so might have to try 'em.Fallout series - mostly 1, some 2. I like 1 way better, myself: 13Diablo series - meh, I'd say Sacred was my favourite hack'n'slash: 13Deus Ex - a personal favourite of mine: 11KOTOR series - 1 was better, but 2 was decent: 10Half-life series - more 2 than not, I wasn't really paying attention: 10There's others like Neverwinter Nights or Planescape or Half-Life or Civilization or a few others that didn't quite make 10.What can we draw from this? Well, Witcher fans like the Witcher. Profound conclusion indeed. Most games were less than fifteen years old, but an awful lot of them were more than five years old - an interesting range. A little nostalgia at work, or do people actually think the games of yore were better by some objective measure? Also, while lots of people love to hate on Oblivion, plenty of others plain love it. I myself like it a lot, but that's only after an extra hundred mods (and 3 gigabytes of content) later. Out-of-the-box is mediocre. All the classic RPGs turn up: Fallout, Planescape, Diablo, Gothic, Neverwinter Nights, Sacred, Knights of the Old Republic... Not really many JRPGs (probably because we're mostly PC gamers here, and above such things
). Big-name recent ones are mostly Mass Effect, Oblivion, and The Witcher.Not so many people saying strategy games or shooters, but when the do, lots of the same ones turn up: Civilization (and Alpha Centauri), Europa Universalis, Age of Empires, Command & Conquer. Shooters, it's mostly Half-Life. Also every so often someone says Prince of Persia (I loved those, personally), or, well, actually I've mostly forgotten by now. Sorry :
.Then there are the weird genre-bending dealies: Deus Ex, System Shock, the ones like that. Lots of Deus Ex fans out there. For good reason, too. Not so many System Shock fans, which is a shame, but I suppose what you'd expect from a ten year old game which had bad public awareness and mediocre sales. Am I right in remembering Psychonauts showing up a couple of places? That game was solid, if completely drug-fueled.Most awesome choices:Albion. I think one person said this one; brilliant and under-appreciated old-school RPG. Good stuff.System Shock (either, though mostly 2 turned up). Didn't make ten, but it's pretty much pure win. A lot like Deus Ex, but with rougher gameplay (sad, but true). Atmosphere is brilliant, though. I dare you to not freak when... well, I won't spoil it.Grim Fandango. Genius. Pure Genius. Monkey Island series is great too, and a lot of the other LucasArts adventure games.But seriously, nobody else is spreading the love for Star Control?