Why even compare CP2077 with RDR2 and why does it matter whether or not the former surpasses the latter? It doesn't make either game better or worse.
I agree. The question is irrelevant.
However, there is one avenue in which CP2077 is clearly superior to RDR2. The fact that you can customize your character. Im dead tired at cliche male protagonists at this point in time. Which has led me to not even finish RDR2 story yet, even though I own it. Same issue applies to W3.
You can customize your character in RDR online, but RDR online is incredibly devoid of things to do, to the point its not immersive or fun enough.