I have said it before, and i will say it again.
Have you played RDR2?
NPC's will react to your clothes, your fitness and your sobriety, also your cleanliness. They will even give you some lip if you wear funny looking hats.
I checked wikipedia about it, avoiding the story parts. There´s written alot about the crafting and survival stuff but how about experience, levels, quests and rewards? Anything like that?