Nobody here but perhaps you is discussing with particular someone, frankly, I don't believe that anyone could be that uniformed how forums work, to believe you. Regardless topic is about case. Besides, you brought EULA up multiple times, I also called you out for it way before, EULA can't grant or take away rights not covered by EULA. You pretend that I haven't made that claim before.
You based your argument on limits of EULA in court of law, which could hold some water, but in case of rights here, there are no such rights in question as CDPR doesn't own, but has licensed Silverhand (copyrighted) and personal rights of Keanu Reeves. They have claim to these rights in extent of their agreement with rights holders and can react if third party violates their rights.
Hardly any of that post is decipherable. And I will call-out your lie once again by repeating that I never once brought-up EULAs in my discussion with you.
What I mentioned elsewhere in this thread concerning EULAs is of no relevance to my discussion with you. There's nothing for you to call-out about that any more than you can call-out the sky for being blue. Did the sky claim to be something else? No. Did I claim I didn't talk about EULAs in this thread? Of course not.
You keep trying to re-frame what you've said to try to work your way out of a hole. You repeatedly claimed I kept bringing-up EULAs in my discussion with you, which, of course, was a lie of yours. And now that that lie has repeatedly failed, you're just nonsensically saying that I've brought-up EULAs multiple times in the thread. No kidding. That has nothing to do with my discussion with you, in which I never once brought-up EULAs.
EULA can't grant or take away rights not covered by EULA. You pretend that I haven't made that claim before
I haven't pretended anything about what you've said. I've only pointed-out what you have in-fact said and done. What
"EULA can't grant or take away rights not covered by EULA" is supposed to mean, I don't even know. How would an EULA do anything apart from mentioning it within the EULA itself? An EULA is specifically the EULA, and isn't text outside of the EULA. But an EULA is not a legal contract and so an EULA doesn't do anything that isn't already done elsewhere, such as by copyright law.
Maybe you meant that an EULA can't grant or take-away rights not covered by copyright or other actual laws.
You based your argument on limits of EULA in court of law, which could hold some water, but in case of rights here, there are no such rights in question as CDPR doesn't own, but has licensed Silverhand (copyrighted) and personal rights of Keanu Reeves. They have claim to these rights in extent of their agreement with rights holders and can react if third party violates their rights.
At least you're finally acknowledging the difference between copyrights and personality rights - which is a positive improvement. But what's your point? CDPR having a right to use the likeness of Keanu Reeves in CP 2077 doesn't mean they have an exclusive right, and it doesn't make them the owner of Keanu Reeves' appearance.
And, as I've mentioned now many times, CDPR's statement about the removal of the mod didn't base their position on protecting their licenses, but on a rule from their modding document.