I think a new protagonist would be extremely unwise UNLESS their story somehow brought them to V at some point, matured and time having passed, which would be absolutely awesome. Players in the base game have invested in their V. If you want to wipe him off the map entirely then that really would best be left for a sequel.Not sure why people are thinking of a completely new protagonist. I'd honestly be pretty disappointed if they did that. I still feel like V's ending lacks resolution and payoff so I'm still hoping they'll deal with that. I hope I'm not setting myself up for disappointment...
Other people have commented that it would be difficult to bring all the endings to a common thread. Actually it looks very easy indeed and far easier than with Witcher 3's bad ending, including with Cyberpunk's short ending (although the latter is the one ending that already provides a narratively satisfying and complete arc). It's worth noting that Witcher 3 doesn't really have quite as distinct endings (apart from the bad one) as people often seem to remember, because the fundamental status of Geralt is exactly the same in all of them. It's the characters around him who differ.
Last edited: