Songlian said:
And this is what I was waiting for. I've been stalking this thread for a while now, reading your opinions about it, because I knew that if there was a good, solid story behind Skyrim, with lots of interesting characters, The Witcher fans would be first to appreciate and recommend it. Turns out Skyrim can take a back seat for now.
You can trust it on Witcher fans to recognise a good story when they see it!
I never played Skyrim for story, I know their games aren't about that and it
is hard to make a good story work in a large, open world. However, they haven't changed a thing for ten years. In fact, they removed Journal as it was in MW (where it was written like a proper journal every time you got a quest update) and now it's just a poorly-assed list of things to do. No indication of the backstory of the quest whatsoever which SUCKS because you're most likely to have many and it's hard to remember who gave you what and their reasons behind it.
I wish they'd focused on game mechanics more. Allow me to do things my way, let ME choose who lives or dies or who I want to side with. You could murder anyone in MW and, if it was an important NPC, the game would let you know - but you could still kill them. It was your choice and your story. I was having fun making up my own story in Skyrim, but I ran into a couple of things that just ruined it for me. I'll play occasionally, but back seat it is.