I don't know why anyone would argue against NG+. For a player like me, I welcome it because during my first play through, I spend a whole lot of time grinding for levels and gear (been doing it since the first Dragon Warrior), which can take away from the overall flow of the game.
"I just spent a couple of hours over the last week grinding, now where did I leave off in the story..."
Heck, I remember the first time I heard of NG+, in Chrono Trigger...a second play through, where I don't have to open every chest and talk to every npc...and I can just focus on the story? Heck yeah!
So with NG+, having the potential to start a new, knowing I can pay full attention to the story, because I've already done the grinding...it's very appealing.
I don't think anyone is arguing
against NG+.
A lot of people just don't get it. Myself included. I genuinely don't get it. Even your argument of
now being able to focus on the story. I genuinely don't get it. Is having to loot a container that distracting to you?
I understand your argument of having to grind for a week and not remembering where you left the story in a game like Chrono Trigger but you don't have to grind in CP2077 at all. Literally zero grinding is necessary. If you want to focus on the story, you can do so without ever grinding. In what way would an NG+ actually improve your focus on the story? Outside of NCPD scanner event and random GIGs, it's all story anyway. Arguably many of the random GIGs also are. How is having to loot a container so detrimental to your enjoyment of the story?
I'm not attacking you here by the way, I am genuinely interested in the answer because I really don't get it. It doesn't get in the way of my enjoyment of the story at all. It doesn't distract me from the story at all. That's why it's impossible for me to support an NG+. To me it all sounds only like what people actually want is to start in god mode.
To be clear, I'm not against it either. Even if the real reason is only to start in god mode. I don't care. What you do in your game doesn't affect me so why should I give a fuck, right? I just don't see it happening, CDPR doesn't seem to be interested in it at all. Although, as
@Kormac67 pointed out, with level scaling in place, it's probably far easier for them to add it.